So I'm curious, you have declared this a success.
I've not said it was a complete success. I think it fails in pricing.
But 'success' is a relative term.
Compared to all the doomsayers who ginned up #cringegate and reveled that fully booked dates were opening up (which was mostly a function of the 90 deadline to pay in full); and they saw that as a sign it is crashing (<insert Nelson's HA HA! here>)... it is indeed a success as a business venture. First four months are just about fully booked. The following three have seen more days becoming fully booked. And Disney is opening up availability to the end of the year. That's a business success for Disney. Not so much for some of their customers who would love to do it but can't afford it.
Sort of like WDW as a whole for many people.
Is this business success sustainable? I don't know. Are there enough people with that kind of disposable income to keep it going? I don't know. How about repeat customers? Well, I could see some people doing it twice, which is enough to hit all the side quests, but after that, they'll know just about how every encounter will go. So, I doubt there will be appreciable repeat business.
If they run out of 'whales,' can they keep it going and be profitable at a lower price point? I don't know. I'm sure they'd have no end of customers at a lower price point, tho.
Is it a success as a Massive Multi-player LARP? From everything we've seen so far, yes. This despite that some people will define LARP in such a narrow way as to exclude what the Halcyon is doing as a "real LARP" and then declare it has failed as a LARP due to that narrow definition.
I've said in this thread way before this started that I've participated and helped run such events in my youth (go, GENCON!). And this looks like to me a very successful LARP. For those who say it isn't a LARP, I'd ask for their credentials to make that judgment other than cherry picking definitions off the Internet.
It is indeed a success... so far. Could that change in the scenario that the initial attendees were somehow not representative of the kind of people who later signed up for this and those later guests find the immersion tedious and the whole thing woefully overpriced, get mad at Disney, and spend the rest of their days on a WDW fan site criticizing anything they can about Disney? I guess. Is that likely? Probably not. Especially since to sign up you have to get over the bar of a live customer service rep who's going to check your assumptions going into this ("
are you aware there is no pool on the Halcyon?").
Disney got people to pay for it for a few months, and the vast majority who've experienced it like it.
So far.
Is it more likely that will continue or not? I don't know.