I think the Skyliner thread was massively overdramatic, as Disney would not have built that kind of system if they did not know how it would handle in the Florida climate, etc. Plus everyone needs transportation.
That said, I think they missed the mark a little here. Both from everything they've released publicly and the people I know who have done test cruises. There's quite a gap between the price point vs actual experience value. My one friend who went said they would do it again if free, or under $2K. His further comments were: "The food, lounge and finale show are the best parts... the rooms are a tiny bit bigger than you'd think, but most of the experiences are cheesy and some are just embarrassing. It's like that element was designed by people who look down upon theme park guests thinking they are all children who will appreciate anything SW that comes their way."
