Kman101
Well-Known Member
I got flamed in 2015...but I'll take the heat on this stance:
Carrie fisher should never have been brought back. Not at all. She just simply was too far gone to be in movies in this capacity.
That's life. I honestly hated seeing Ford and hamill awkwardly tiptoe around in as well...but fisher couldn't even talk after all her "living" Over the years.
So now these 3 movies are tied to her...and she honestly wasn't even resembling the character any more. How do you have "sharp tongue" when you can't actually move your mouth?
They should have done these in the 90's when everybody wanted them...as anyone reasonable could have determined...except apparently guys named "Jorge".
But that's another battle.
And in the 90s none of Carrie, Mark or Harrison would have done the movies. Maybe Mark. Carrie maybe could have been talked into it. But you couldn't do the movies as is then because the likelihood of them doing it is pretty slim. This whole "it's cool to go back to your character from 30 years ago" is a more recent trend. If you don't go back, you're shredded.
I hope you're perfect when you reach Carrie's age
I think we're all pretty aware of how you feel towards the current crop of movies You seem to talk about it quite a bit. And you seem to be unwilling to realize other people may have liked the movie.
Personally, I didn't rush to go see it in the theater and I haven't for any of them. I enjoy them, I don't take them too seriously. They're fun. I don't like some of the things I've read, and one was no surprised because I feared they'd do it and they did.
Considering George did a less than stellar job in the 90s/00s with the other three movies I'm glad he's not involved. Sorry but those movies weren't the most well received (I "grew up" with them and they weren't good) and George was fairly panned for them, IIRC, but now some people (not saying you) think they're fine now and the new movies are terrible. What happens in 20 years when said same people now think these new movies were actually good.
But I'm rambling. Everyone has different tastes but you seem determined to insist TFA was a total and complete failure. That's your perogative, but that isn't quite the truth. Could it have gone better? Sure it could have. I'm sure they're frustrated because they set very lofty expectations, but I don't think they're throwing up their hands and throwing in the towel (which is what some seem to be implying, which is wishful thinking). I do believe they may not be sure where to go and they're just riding on the high, which isn't necessarily smart.
Frankly, SOLO isn't needed. Movies like this will be the ones that muddle the waters and kill the franchise. But I liked Rogue One for what it was. I know it's easy to dislike something because it didn't live up to how we set it up in our minds (again, not saying you). Personally I've stopped doing that and it's nice to not get so worked up over things that just aren't in my control.
Last edited: