Sure, not getting FP+ most certainly is "punishment" since it means standing in line needlessly for potentially hours each day; hours that could have avoiding by signing up for My Disney Experience. Unless, of course, you prefer standing in line and experiencing fewer attractions each day.
The current FP system is free, equally accessible to all guests. FP+ changes that; you have to register into Disney's billion dollar data collection system.
Universal charges for its Express Pass, either directly or through onsite resort rooms. What Universal is doing is pure capitalism. Disney could have gone the same route, could have charged for FP+ yet they opted to make FP+ "free" as long as you register in their database.
Perhaps more than anything, that should give you an appreciation of exactly how much Disney values your information.
Quoting the Gordon Gekko character in the film
Wall Street, “The most valuable commodity I know of is information.”
Obviously, Disney agrees which should be cause for concern amongst all of us.
And I don't need FP or FP+. I simply go to Universal where they stick to old fashioned capitalism.