TUX'S REVIEWS (PT 1)
____________________________________________________________
@DisneyManOne 's Alice In Wonderland
Having an attraction that wasn't originally planned and in fact was made due to factors out of the company's control is certainly a very interesting choice creative wise and realism wise since it's something that doesn't happen very frequently throughout the forums, and yet I like it not only for the above factors but also because it helps to logically bridge why the company chose to do Alice for the Magic Kingdom instead of Toad. My favorite thing about this submission is how the way the ride is described makes it genuinely feel like a 1970's classic fantasyland attraction. Well done!
Creativity - 8/10
Detail - 9/10
Realism - 10/10
Presentation - 8/10
OVERALL SCORE - 35/40
________________________________________________________
@orlando678- 's The Haunted Chateau
I can tell this is something that you were clearly very passionate about, given the crazy amount of detail and effort that went into the plot of the attraction, and yet it never feels out of place in Fantasyland due to the fairy tale plot. It feels like it would fit right at home at Tokyo Disneyland with hints of Paris Disneyland mixed in! I also enjoyed some of the symbolism I noticed throughout the project like the flowers and the crow element. The only thing I'm worried about is displaying a witch trial in a Disney park, but to be fair Mr. Toad sent you to hell at the end, and Alien Encounter made you watch a maintenance man get brutally killed by the alien and then stimulated his remains splattering onto you, plus it's kind of the point since this is supposed to be the counterpart to Phantom Manor, so I'll let it slide.
Creativity - 10/10
Realism - 9/10
Detail - 9/10
Presentation - 7/10
OVERALL SCORE - 35/40
____________________________________________________
@NigelChanning09 's Bald Mountain: A Disney Villains Adventure
I generally like the idea of this attraction, however, I am quite curious on how the ride system operates with the boat and rollercoaster transition. It sounds like such a cool system and I wouldn't mind if you added a section focusing on the mechanics of the ride along with it. I do like most of the creative choices you made with how the villains interact with the guests and how they fight back. However, I feel as if the write out could use more detail.
Creativity - 9/10
Realism - 9/10
Detail - 7/10
Presentation - 6/10
OVERALL SCORE - 31/40
_____________________________________________________________________________
@NigelChanning09 's Toy Story Expansion
I just want to say how I love how creative you were when choosing the themes for the attractions you created for this area, with mentions of Star Command, Toy Story That Time Forgot, and Toy Story Four for your respective attractions which is very refreshing compared to how Toy Story attractions throughout the park usually just stick around Toy Story 1-3. I'm not entirely sure how the water elements tie into That Time Forgot though, it would've probably worked better with Hawaiian Vacation, though I still like it. Once again, more detail would be appreciated but you're doing a great job so far!
Creativity - 9/10
Realism - 9/10
Detail - 7/10
Presentation - 7/19
OVERALL SCORE - 32/40
______________________________________________________________________________
@DashHaber 's Wreck-It-Ralph: Arcade Clean Up
I think this is overall a very solid attraction that I think could be a good replacement for Toy Story Mania in Hollywood Studios given that it doesn't contrast against Toy Story Land too much. While there seems to be a bit of an inconsistency between whether the main threat is a virus or a Cybug invasion similar to the one from the movie, it's overall still a very small nitpick and doesn't detract from the ride overall. It's a very high quality attraction that I could see Disney opening up and I can't wait to see what you continue to do in the future!
Creativity: 9/10
Realism: 9/10
Detail: 9/10
Presentation: 7/10
OVERALL SCORE - 34/10
__________________________________________________________________________
@Pufflefan 's Dream Boats
I'm extremely happy that you decided to go all out onto your presentation seeing that it's one of your biggest strengths as an Imagineer and what can I say but it's extremely pretty? While this ride doesn't feel too complete, you did acknowledge that and it's not like the Crystal Grotto where it's void of anything to really see. While once again like some of the others, I feel like you could have put more detail into the writing aspects of the project, but the aesthetic purposes help make up for that.
Creativity: 9/10
Realism: 9/10
Detail: 7/10
Presentation: 9/10
OVERALL SCORE - 34/10
_____________________________________________________________________________
@Outbound 's Grizzly Family Vacation
And now for my favorite attraction out of all the currently existing ones, the Grizzly Family Vacation. It's a fairly simple ride that doesn't take up too much space while still majorly helping California Adventure as California Adventure could really need an original E-Ticket not currently in the other parks similarly to Grizzly River Run. It's a very simple plot that plays around with some very typical character archetypes but it's so over the top in it's plot that I can't help but love it. I mean the entire plot is basically a bear almost drowning a whole family by launching them off a waterfall because they disobeyed park regulations. Yet at the same time I unironically think it's a extremely cool yet cute attraction with Cranium Command type humor.
Creativity: 10/10
Realism: 9/10
Detail: 9/10
Presentation: 9/10
OVERALL SCORE - 37/10