That's a bit melodramatic. By banning smoking in the park altogether you're not turning them into "criminals". Pretty much every bar and restaurant and store in America does not allow smoking and you can't smoke in your hotel rooms at Disney...yet smoking is still legal.
Magic Kingdom can very easily ban smoking as can the rest of the parks. There is plenty of real estate on which you can smoke on Walt Disney World property. Banning it in the parks makes perfect sense.
Especially if you look at it from an environmental standpoint. They have banned plastic straws even though WDW is nowhere near the ocean. But cigarettes release carcinogens into the atmosphere and the cigarette butts are also pollutants.
Not to mention second hand smoke being more dangerous for non-smokers. By allowing the second hand smoke in the parks Disney is making children and non-smokers susceptible to the dangers of second hand smoke.
And from a safety point of view: Disney mandates that we wear seat belts, lap bands, etc. and they have a litany of safety rules in the parks to keep people out of danger. Smoking is proven to be dangerous to your health so by mandating that smoking not be allowed in the parks...Disney is just ensuring the safety of its visitors.
1. I said nothing about either allowing or banning smoking in
enclosed areas. I was among those overjoyed when they finally stopped the "smoking/nonsmoking" areas in restaurants, etc. - as if the smoke was going to stay on one side of the room! But, people could, and can, smoke once they leave the premises. The same with hotels until they out and out banned smoking in any rooms - it was pretty gross the last time I stayed in a 100% booked hotel and was put in a smoking room. But, they did(and do) have designated smoking areas outside - and they are getting further and further away from where non-smokers have to walk. So, as I stated, I am not happy about having
designated outdoor smoking areas in the park, but also do not think they should be removed, and a total ban on smoking be instituted. I also think that CMs should police it better - but seeing how hostile people can become when instructed to follow rules, I can understand why they might prefer to overlook it. But putting a total ban would require people to actually leave the park, and come back in through the gates, security, etc again. Which might make them more likely to try and make their own designated area.
2. I have encountered anti-smokers who would like smoking to be made illegal, as stated. Put on the same level as opiods. Thereby making what was previously legal activity illegal. What was "dramatic" about my repeating what I have heard? I didn't say it - and IMO those who did say it might have been a bit dramatic. Or just expressing their view about something they feel strongly about due to personal experience with the health dangers.
Right now, there are various restrictions that vary state by state - and even city by city. Some states have made smoking under certain circumstances "illegal" but only punishable with fines and community service - no jail time. In my particular city, bar smoking is up to the owner - unless a certain percentage of sales come from food service, and then indoor smoking is banned. But still, smoking is allowed outdoors, so many restaurants have outdoor seating.
Overeating and alcohol are also dangerous to your health, and yet Disney has the yearly Food & Wine Festival. Granted, no amount of smoking (and according to the latest study, alcohol) is safe, perhaps Disney should remove all but organic, low fat, low salt, low sugar items to keep people safe? Now I
am being purposely dramatic.