If I remember right the all stars was going to be ~$100 cheaper after you factor in resort fees, parking, ect.
Overall we went with the Hilton for a few reasons:
- We already decided on a rental car regardless so that price wasn't a factor. However, a Disney bus with a stroller/toddler can be quite tough so we would drive anyway. Thus, Disney transportation didn't matter to us.
- We really like Disney springs and will probably go there at least twice during our trip, the ability to walk there is a huge perk to us
- No way to guarantee a king room at the all-stars. Not a deal breaker, but still a plus for the Hilton when a second bed isn't needed (he still sleeps in a portable crib)
- Nicer/bigger looking hotel rooms (380 sqft vs 260sqft)
- Nicer looking lobby/grab and go food options. Not just 1 big cafeteria
- No "hike" to the food options, like you might at the value resorts. Hotel is more compact
- Kiddy pool actually looks better at Hilton (big pool doesn't matter for us)
- My son is young enough (he'll be about 21 months) that the big props of the all stars/ whimsy of the resort/room don't really matter.
Maybe I'm wrong and I will end up hating it and never staying there again!
In the past, I've stayed at the Beach Club, Boardwalk, Swan, Dolphin, All stars, Pop Centry, Universal's Royal Pacific, and the Fairfield Lake Buena Vista. So, the Hilton will be something new to try!
View attachment 813283View attachment 813284