JimboJones123
Well-Known Member
33% of the Fastpass line was GAC! Crazy. Sad, but crazy.I don't think this blog post has been linked to yet:
http://www.disunplugged.com/2013/01/16/guest-assistance-cards-vs-fastpass-let-the-battle-begin/
33% of the Fastpass line was GAC! Crazy. Sad, but crazy.I don't think this blog post has been linked to yet:
http://www.disunplugged.com/2013/01/16/guest-assistance-cards-vs-fastpass-let-the-battle-begin/
For those who do not think the abuse is quite as bad as it is being made out to be. Let me just say that a big name attraction at the Magic Kingdom kept count of how many GAC guests were admitted into their attraction's Fastpass queue over a period of a week. Let's say the estimated amount of guests that this specific attractions aim to achieve in an hour of operation (taking into consideration some aspects of general operation is around 1800 guests. In an average hour, around 350 guests were admitted using a GAC card. That means that approximately 20% of the guests served in that hour were admitted using a GAC which admitted them through the Fastpass line where they had minimal to no wait. It is up to you to form an opinion on whether that amount is reasonable or not or if also tells if the system is being abused or if WDW just attracts many guests that face a variety of disabilities or special needs.
They have been tracking them at another E-ticket attraction at another park as well. The capacity is around 2000, and they have had more than a few hours with 400, 500, yes even 600 (the last one happened a couple of times over New Year's). That's 20-30% of the people who rode. And it's not entirely due to there being too many GACs - it's that the same families use them over and over again. Those multiple rides add up significantly. Maybe 1% of the guests have a GAC, but they can account for over a quarter of the ridership? Something needs to change there. And yes, there are some people who truly need accommodations - they use the GAC maybe once or twice just so they can experience the attraction the same as everyone else, but even their shortened wait time is being unfairly increased by those abusing the very generous system.
As for how CMs can tell who "needs" it and who doesn't - it's all in the attitude. Shoving the GAC in their face, loudly calling it a "magic ticket," bragging about the number of times they've ridden the ride despite the triple-digit wait in the stand-by line thanks to their "special fastpass"...typically signs of someone with a feeling of entitlement than someone with a disability. I find that those who need it are usually more grateful, humble, and considerate with its use.
They have been tracking them at another E-ticket attraction at another park as well. The capacity is around 2000, and they have had more than a few hours with 400, 500, yes even 600 (the last one happened a couple of times over New Year's). That's 20-30% of the people who rode. And it's not entirely due to there being too many GACs - it's that the same families use them over and over again. Those multiple rides add up significantly. Maybe 1% of the guests have a GAC, but they can account for over a quarter of the ridership? Something needs to change there. And yes, there are some people who truly need accommodations - they use the GAC maybe once or twice just so they can experience the attraction the same as everyone else, but even their shortened wait time is being unfairly increased by those abusing the very generous system.
As for how CMs can tell who "needs" it and who doesn't - it's all in the attitude. Shoving the GAC in their face, loudly calling it a "magic ticket," bragging about the number of times they've ridden the ride despite the triple-digit wait in the stand-by line thanks to their "special fastpass"...typically signs of someone with a feeling of entitlement than someone with a disability. I find that those who need it are usually more grateful, humble, and considerate with its use.
I do have an honest question for GAC users. Do you face issues when it comes to receiving similar assistance at restaurants, gift shops, transportation, meet and greets, or other areas where lines and crowds form? Do you feel that there should be ways to accommodate you at these locations, is it even needed, or do you think its a fair balance? I do ask this with all good intentions so I hope no one feels like they are under attack. I very curious to hear how families live through the rest of their vacation at a busy theme park resort.
I really think multiple rides are a huge issue. However again, I want to point to my own family this trip and some issues that weren't really GAC related and how we handled them.They have been tracking them at another E-ticket attraction at another park as well. The capacity is around 2000, and they have had more than a few hours with 400, 500, yes even 600 (the last one happened a couple of times over New Year's). That's 20-30% of the people who rode. And it's not entirely due to there being too many GACs - it's that the same families use them over and over again. Those multiple rides add up significantly. Maybe 1% of the guests have a GAC, but they can account for over a quarter of the ridership? Something needs to change there. And yes, there are some people who truly need accommodations - they use the GAC maybe once or twice just so they can experience the attraction the same as everyone else, but even their shortened wait time is being unfairly increased by those abusing the very generous system.
As for how CMs can tell who "needs" it and who doesn't - it's all in the attitude. Shoving the GAC in their face, loudly calling it a "magic ticket," bragging about the number of times they've ridden the ride despite the triple-digit wait in the stand-by line thanks to their "special fastpass"...typically signs of someone with a feeling of entitlement than someone with a disability. I find that those who need it are usually more grateful, humble, and considerate with its use.
That being said, I am wondering where some people on this board have managed to have such amazing medical diagnostic powers to just see someone and say since they are walking that they have nothing wrong. Yes, admit-ably some of these people might not have anything wrong but that still does not justify accusing anyone without knowing their backgrounds.
Please don't let anyone here influence your decision to go to disney. It's no one else's business you do what's right for your family.Restaurants can be a problem. Just recently my autistic son had a meltdown at a local restaurant he'd been in numerous times without issue. This time apparently the noise was too much for him and we had to leave. The judgmental looks from others who think he just needs a spanking is always fun. The funny part is we could have stayed and just dealt with it the best we could but we feel like it wouldn't be fair to others in the restaurant so we left. Needless to say we don't get to eat out much as a family.
Gift shops we avoid unless they are relatively empty and we can get in or out. Even then there are still sometimes issues with my son knocking things over because his physical coordination isn't as good as it could be.
Transportation on the bus system at WDW is always an adventure. Sometimes if the lines are too long we let everyone else get on and wait for another bus that may be less crowded. That often means we miss time at the parks because we're waiting for transportation. In a few weeks we're going to just drive to the parks in our vehicle and see if it helps.
We don't do meet and greets ever since they don't accept a GAC and there's just no way my son could wait in a line that long without a meltdown. It's a shame too because I'm sure he'd absolutely love to meet his two favorite characters Mickey and Winnie the Pooh. I finally managed to get reservations for character dining this year. Hopefully it will turn out well.
So basically we miss out on a lot of things everyone else gets to enjoy at the parks. We don't do many vacations together except for WDW every year or two because my son LOVES WDW. The way he comes out of his shell when we arrive is a sight to see. Even if he only gets to ride Pooh a few times it's worth all the trouble we go through just to see him laugh and have a good time.
So there you go. That's a typical day at WDW for our family. Even with a GAC we get to do a tiny fraction of what a regular guest gets to do. Most of our time is spent trying to make sure our son doesn't have a meltdown that impedes other people's enjoyment of the parks. We could just keep him at home like was mentioned by someone earlier in the thread I suppose. Perhaps it would be better for everyone else if we did. I already feel guilty enough using a GAC the three or four times we do while on vacation. Threads like this make me feel like we should just stop going permanently so as to not bother anyone else.
Who cares, if it works for the majority of the disabled then it works, I'm honestly too busy having fun on my vacation to worry about it. We can't control all the variables. If they change the system I promise people will figure out how to con it. Simple human nature, some folks don't have scruples. I don't see the effect that a lot of people are complaining about, so the fast pass line is 3/4 minutes longer. Not that big of deal. There are people that truly need the pass and there are people that con the system, it's not anything new, but if one person gets to experience something great who am I to judgeOh for the love of Walt...
nobody anywhere is saying ANYTHING like "oh that family right there doesn't look disabled, so they are definitely scamming!" But when 500 of these cards are written out PER DAY, PER PARK, then yes, a vast amount of these people are not actually disabled!
You guys think, from your one visit a year or less that you know so much about this, but maybe you should listen to the people who deal with it on a daily basis who keep re-affirming that the cards are massively scammed. If you guys could just do that... then you know, maybe we could continue to have an actual discussion on a legitimate problem that IS having a negative impact on EVERYONE'S time in the parks, including those who are legitimately disabled.
Most people aren't denying that the GAC cards are massively scammed. However, when someone comes along and posts a picture of an overweight person in an ECV (or simply some vitriolic commentary), and then that post goes on to receive 5-10 'likes', it conveys a strong sense of the hostility that many disabled people actually face in the parks. These two conversations can't be kept separate, because inevitably someone will cast judgment where they shouldn't, which results in a backlash from the people who feel offended and vilified by the judgmental posters here. Sadly, it's not limited to the boards - these disabled people often receive nasty stares (and the occasional verbal berating) on the basis of their appearance, which means many of you are taking out your bitterness and hostility on the wrong people (and ruining what should be a joyous occasion for them).Oh for the love of Walt...
nobody anywhere is saying ANYTHING like "oh that family right there doesn't look disabled, so they are definitely scamming!" But when 500 of these cards are written out PER DAY, PER PARK, then yes, a vast amount of these people are not actually disabled!
You guys think, from your one visit a year or less that you know so much about this, but maybe you should listen to the people who deal with it on a daily basis who keep re-affirming that the cards are massively scammed. If you guys could just do that... then you know, maybe we could continue to have an actual discussion on a legitimate problem that IS having a negative impact on EVERYONE'S time in the parks, including those who are legitimately disabled.
As for how CMs can tell who "needs" it and who doesn't - it's all in the attitude. Shoving the GAC in their face, loudly calling it a "magic ticket," bragging about the number of times they've ridden the ride despite the triple-digit wait in the stand-by line thanks to their "special fastpass"...typically signs of someone with a feeling of entitlement than someone with a disability. I find that those who need it are usually more grateful, humble, and considerate with its use.
I completely understand what you're saying - cast members probably have a great gauge on who's faking and who isn't (even if they can't act on it).This. You get to be able to tell which guests really need it before too long, and has nothing to do with what they "look" like. Guests that need it come seeking accommodation, and you sense that. It's not something they want to do, but rather something they need. They are often grateful when you explain the nature of the attraction or make offers for other accommodations. Guests that abuse it have an attitude of entitlement and tend to get annoyed when you look too closely at the card, or act like you're wasting their time when you ask any questions ("will you be able to step into the ride vehicle?") or make other suggestions. Unfortunately as Cast Members, we're not allowed to act on our judgment...
Something else ignored, especially at MK, is the fact that most of the time it takes well more than an hour to get both in and out of the park. Typically, an hour each way is very ambitious for us. Even with the VERY FAR AWAY handicapped parking.Restaurants can be a problem. Just recently my autistic son had a meltdown at a local restaurant he'd been in numerous times without issue. This time apparently the noise was too much for him and we had to leave. The judgmental looks from others who think he just needs a spanking is always fun. The funny part is we could have stayed and just dealt with it the best we could but we feel like it wouldn't be fair to others in the restaurant so we left. Needless to say we don't get to eat out much as a family.
Gift shops we avoid unless they are relatively empty and we can get in or out. Even then there are still sometimes issues with my son knocking things over because his physical coordination isn't as good as it could be.
Transportation on the bus system at WDW is always an adventure. Sometimes if the lines are too long we let everyone else get on and wait for another bus that may be less crowded. That often means we miss time at the parks because we're waiting for transportation. In a few weeks we're going to just drive to the parks in our vehicle and see if it helps.
We don't do meet and greets ever since they don't accept a GAC and there's just no way my son could wait in a line that long without a meltdown. It's a shame too because I'm sure he'd absolutely love to meet his two favorite characters Mickey and Winnie the Pooh. I finally managed to get reservations for character dining this year. Hopefully it will turn out well.
So basically we miss out on a lot of things everyone else gets to enjoy at the parks. We don't do many vacations together except for WDW every year or two because my son LOVES WDW. The way he comes out of his shell when we arrive is a sight to see. Even if he only gets to ride Pooh a few times it's worth all the trouble we go through just to see him laugh and have a good time.
So there you go. That's a typical day at WDW for our family. Even with a GAC we get to do a tiny fraction of what a regular guest gets to do. Most of our time is spent trying to make sure our son doesn't have a meltdown that impedes other people's enjoyment of the parks. We could just keep him at home like was mentioned by someone earlier in the thread I suppose. Perhaps it would be better for everyone else if we did. I already feel guilty enough using a GAC the three or four times we do while on vacation. Threads like this make me feel like we should just stop going permanently so as to not bother anyone else.
I have not been feeling well lately, if I send you a recent picture could you tell me what my illness is, will save me on medical bills TIA
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.