Oh for the love of Walt...
nobody anywhere is saying ANYTHING like "oh that family right there doesn't look disabled, so they are definitely scamming!" But when 500 of these cards are written out PER DAY, PER PARK, then yes, a vast amount of these people are not actually disabled!
You guys think, from your one visit a year or less that you know so much about this, but maybe you should listen to the people who deal with it on a daily basis who keep re-affirming that the cards are massively scammed. If you guys could just do that... then you know, maybe we could continue to have an actual discussion on a legitimate problem that IS having a negative impact on EVERYONE'S time in the parks, including those who are legitimately disabled.
If the Magic Kingdom averages 42,000 guests per day, 500 GAC cards per day seems low! That is 1.19% of the guests are disabled and are using GAC cards. Many guests in wheelchairs don't know about the cards and find out after touring the parks for a day or two. From the ADA (US Census 2010), approximately 18% of the US population has a minor to severe disability with 12.7% being severe, 4.4% of all individuals in the US over the age of six require personal assistance.
Now... There is obviously a problem with individuals using a GAC to gain advantage, I have seen it on many occasions but if it happens twice per hour, every hour on most rides it negatively impacts the guests waiting in the special queues for disabled guests much more than normal guests. BTMRR takes two groups in at a time, each group waits for the third train and only the third train which takes 5-6 minutes per group. Earlier this month I counted 14 guests in front of us, the "standby" line was 35 minutes, and there is no way anyone legitimately in a wheelchair would choose to wait an extra 35 minutes to avoid climbing a few stairs.
If anyone should be mad and upset it is those of us that DO need them, use them based on moral principals, don't abuse the access, get to enjoy all the leering of many guests, arrogant and nasty remarks while getting on the bus (my wife has actually been accused of "faking" it,) and then get to wait longer at times because a group of guests are cheating the system, especially when you are behind them in line. The individuals that abuse the GAC system are usually a small percentage of guests we run into in these lines. I truly believe the abuse is overstated here as an excuse to rant.
This past Dec/Jan we stayed at both CB and resorts, split at 10 days each. We had go to the Martinique or Port Royale bus stop simply because most of the time there were already too many guests on the bus for them to load us, we should have loaded at Trinidad North. My wife always offers to transfer, there are three of us, so that we don't take any extra space. Never have we used an ECV, they take up valuable bus space and Disney does not allow guests to stay on them while the bus is moving meaning that one ECV guest takes FOUR seats. That is a personal choice on our part to try to make sure we are not getting any "special" access but still we hear comments, see the looks, etc. We always have to get to the bus stop 20-30 minutes before we need to in order to make sure she could get on, we have had busses with 10-12 guests riding state that there was no room. We always get unloaded LAST, taking an extra 10-15 minutes while all the average guests have disembarked and are going to have fun.
Parades and fireworks are always a royal pain, if we are not watching them we have to completely avoid the area because they become too congested, walkways become too narrow and guests walking WILL NOT stay moving the way castmember's direct them too. As we visit during periods when my son is not in school, Christmas and summer, the parks are very busy. We have all but given up trying to watch fireworks and parades because have repeatedly, not all the time, been told only one guest per wheelchair is allowed for space, this is a family park! We have to move through the groups much slower, to avoid people jumping over her, NOT KIDDING, we have had adults actually jump over my wife's legs while dragging their children over her.
After visiting WDW since 1999 nearly every year, sometimes twice a year we are very used to people like you, making comments on the bus, in lines, etc. Generally speaking anyone in a wheelchair would gladly swap places with you and wait in a 2 hour line, I know my wife word. Please, please get of the high horse and get over yourself.