Disneydreamer23
Well-Known Member
So excited!!!
Ahem.
This is absolutely the worst thing that has ever happened to any of the Mansions since the first one opened in 1969. Bar none.
This is a crime.
Eric Jacobson, Eric Goodman, and Pete Carsillo have destroyed something that was very special. They should be ashamed.
So how do you really feel?:hammer:
I have a question? Won't this delay or slow the Que line? I thought that fast pass was the answer to the long lines, and delays in getting into the rides, and now with the interactive elements, won't more people be "playing" with the stuff instead of moving along?
:shrug::veryconfu
You can demonstrate pretty conclusively that what you see in the HM is supposed to be understood as a one-time, unique event, not something that happens nightly (or whatever). The Caretaker's look of astonishment pretty well settles it: he's never seen anything like this before.
http://www.wdwmagic.com/Attractions...e-opens-for-guest-previews-this-afternoon.htm
Incredible job by WDI on this!
Doesn't hold water. The Caretaker is not simply terrified, he's astonished. Everything about him shouts this at you: Holding up the lantern (a gesture that says, "I need to get a better look at this"), the movement of his head slowly in different directions (he's looking around), and his facial expression itself (yes, this is subjective, but honestly, can you deny that he looks not merely frightened but dumbstruck?).Or the Caretaker is Luigi. Even after dealing with spooks, often the silly kind, both are still easily terrified but keep going on with their job.
No one there thought that that very substantive and interesting discussion was "derailment." My take on the Caretaker stands. I cite evidence that is actually there to support it. I haven't seen a shred of evidence cited in support of other views.Bravery and fearlessness overlap, but they aren't quite the same thing.
Cowardly as he is, our silent guardian and watchful protector can take it.
The Caretaker is the hero Gotham deserves, but not the one that should be discussed right now, because this thread's just going to turn into the same "One-time vs Average Day" argument the Micechat thread derailed into.
No one there thought that that very substantive and interesting discussion was "derailment." My take on the Caretaker stands. I cite evidence that is actually there to support it. I haven't seen a shred of evidence cited in support of other views.
Not sure how liked the IDW Mansion comics are among fans, but their reason for the Caretaker being there is rather nice, and I think it's the best reason I've heard. He works day in and day out at the mansion, despite being terrified by ghosts, because his former wife is a ghost who lives in the mansion, and he can have a picnic lunch with her every day." Rather sweet and a bit funny at the same time. Very Marc Davis.
Regardless of that interpretation, I am in the camp that says he's been dealing with it for a while. It's no secret that the ghosts make the mansion and it's grounds their home, the Ghost Host frequently tells us how popular it is, and how many ghosts live there. Madam Leota isn't bringing the ghosts into view for the first time, she's doing it like she always has for the master's guests. As for the Caretaker and why he puts up with it, who really knows, besides the Imagineers who started it. Maybe Gracey pays well.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.