The idea of Pleasure Island died the day they ungated the island, then outsourced locations which made it impossible to gate the island again. I have no problem with there being a mix of entertainment options. I do have a problem with how they went about it and the idea that all of HW will be outsourced, which means we aren't gonna get Disney creativity. If we end up with more laughable 1980s(if that) animatronic figures in loud restaraunts, HW is going to suck, plain and simple.
If they would recognize the need for more adult options and open a comedy club(be it AC or CW) and a dance club or 2(MDP/8-trax) they could have that mix without creating the "party" atmosphere that drove PI in its early days.
Either that or create another party area on property. Lord knows there is enough land for them to do so if they desire. I don't really care WHERE the clubs are located, but I want something to do at night. PI got blamed for the West Side business going downhill, but after PI closed, 2 stores closed, 1 cut itself in half, and the entire place has been laughable. I'm most upset that this whole time, the clubs could have at least been open, making money, and I could be having fun there, but instead, short sighted decisions lead to a wasteland for 2+ years.