I'll say why feel it was a fail as I cannot speak for everyone else... I watched online as Lou Mongello streamed the Parks announcement presentation... Staggs is boring... He presented NOTHING of substance... He rehashed everything already known about the stateside parks... He was monotone... And despite concept art about DLS, the presentation was boring and just fell flat... In fairness, Disney did seem to hit a grand slam during their Movie Studio presentation... I'm trying to be fair and balanced...
The original D23 gave up major announcements (Ok so the online community already knew about them via leaks) but still... We got some good hype... Disney seemed to be setting up D23 as a major convention on the same level as ComicCon or the video game conventions (forgive me, I forget the name of it, I know G4 broadcasts live from there, mind isn't on full working mode after a late night and I'm too lazy to look it up right now LOL)... They should try to improve on the first D23 and make the second one better... And while they seemed to have done that in MOST areas, again, the parks presentation fell flat... The presentation just felt as if there was no life or excitement to it... I really felt like Staggs didn't want to be there... Joe Rhode or Rodhe however you spell it, was the only speaker who had life to his presentation and he wasn't even there live... That's why I felt it fell flat and was a fail, not because we didn't get any major announcements...
Many of us felt the presentation was a disaster... Go read the D23 thread... many of us were hoping, after the outpouring of complaints about the disaster that was the parks presentation, that Disney would learn something about its fans... After last night, they haven't...