Nubs70
Well-Known Member
For me and my family, the last trip:For 2 years, Iger and Rasulo have been referring to metrics (most of which they don't want to share with the public) that indicate that MyMagic+ is working. We have to keep in mind that Wall Street views "working" as meaning that profits are up. Everything else is a sideshow.
"Show me the money."
The good news is that Disney's Parks & Resorts (P&R) profits are up. The bad news is that, so far, Iger and Rasulo have not attributed this to MyMagic+. To be clear, they want to declare MyMagic+ a financial success. The fact that they have not yet done so is telling.
Please recall that earlier this year, even CEO Bob Iger said:
We did see in the quarter a positive impact to the bottom line from MyMagic+, just the beginnings of it. We will continue to see more of that. But we do not have data that we can share with you right now about specific guest spending.
More than 6 months after MyMagic+ was made available to all Guests, Iger still was not claiming MyMagic+ was a financial success, "just the beginnings of it". Do you think Iger had to wait 6 months or longer to declare Cars Land at Disney's California Adventure a financial success?
Please consider that in the most recently reported fiscal quarter:
Based on publically available information, Universal's less expensive investment in Diagon Alley has proven to be considerably more profitable than Disney's investment in MyMagic+.
- P&R's domestic revenue is up 10.6% but Universal Theme Parks' revenue is up 29.9%.
- P&R's operating income is up 20.0% but Universal Theme Parks' operating income is up 65.1%.
- P&R's domestic Per Capita Guest Spending (PCGS) at the theme parks is up 4%, the lowest increase since the 1st quarter of fiscal year 2010.
- P&R domestic hotel occupancy is up 8% while Metro Orlando's occupancy (excluding WDW) is up 6.5%.
- P&R's domestic Per Room Guest Spending (PRGS) is up 3.6% while Metro Orlando's hotel rates (excluding Disney) are up 3.7%.
So far, I see no signs that MyMagic+ is "working", at least not in the way that any CEO worth their salt would define it.
For me, an interesting metric that Disney does not publish would be length of ticket sold at WDW. In 2013, it was Rasulo who said:
So if we can get people to plan their vacation before they leave home, we know that we get more time with them. We get a bigger share of their wallet.
Is Disney "get[ting] more time with them"? An increase in the average length of ticket sold would be evidence of that.
Attendance is an interesting measure but, even with a 7% jump in the most recent quarter at Disney, it's apparent that with revenue up 29.9%, the jump at Universal is even greater. More people are coming to Orlando but it does not appear that they are spending more time at WDW. My opinion is that Diagon Alley was the big draw in 2014. Diagon Alley and a rebounding economy is why Orlando area business is booming right now, not MyMagic+.
Back when the original Wizzarding World of Harry Potter opened in 2010, I recall a Disney spokesperson saying, "A rising tide lifts all boats". (Sorry, I don't have the link for this but thing it was in an Orlando Sentinel article.) Diagon Alley is great but Universal Orlando remains no more than a 2 day stop for most vacationers, meaning Disney is the primary beneficiary for the remaining vacation days. Therefore, I have to ask myself, "Would Disney's attendance be up 7% if Diagon Alley hadn't opened?"
People need to step away from the endless "I love/hate MyMagic+" bickering. Whether you and I personally like or dislike MyMagic+ is not particularly important at the moment. To Disney, the more important question is: "Are Guests spending more as a result of MyMagic+".
So far, the answer is "no".
Length of stay: 7 days
Resort: Wyndham Bonnet Creek
UNI days: 2 + 1 free
WDW days: 0
Free Range Days: 4
Only money spent on Disney: Lunch for 4 at Earl of Sandwich.