Mickey and Minnie's Runaway Railway confirmed

Donaldfan1934

Well-Known Member
Since there isn’t one style of MM, that would have been the case regardless.
Yes, but the difference is the previous styles of Mickey have proven their timeless familiarity throughout the decades. Thinking of the ride potential for the previous eras of Mickey really makes me wish that Disney went with the intitially rumored "The Great Mickey Ride" instead where we would've gotten scenes devoted each of them.
 

Donaldfan1934

Well-Known Member
If each one was timeless, then how come they kept changing 'em?
I didn't mean timeless in the literal sense. I meant that each era of the character is eternally iconic. For example, Mickey's earliest shorts from the late 20's/early 30's may seem rudimentary when compared to later ones, but imagery of Mickey flying planes, selling hot dogs, and at the wheel of Steamboat Willie are iconic to this day. And because their everlasting place in the Disney iconography, I was suggesting that it would've been a better idea to use them in a GMR style Mickey ride as rummored would've been better than what we're getting.
 

tirian

Well-Known Member
Saying people hate it is essentially the same as claiming it is unpopular.

I don’t think merch sales is a good way to indicate that anyway. After all, a lot of people are simply more familiar with the classic design so higher sales make sense, it isn’t necessarily a comment on the quality of the new design.

If you like the visual style, that’s great. I don’t care. No reason to keep going back and forth.
 
Last edited:

MisterPenguin

President of Animal Kingdom
Premium Member
Also 2:59 is hilarious.

1530486529863.png


in the whale
 
Last edited:

Buried20KLeague

Well-Known Member
131107mag-mickey-mouse1.jpg
walt-disney-mickey-mouse-classic_a-G-9067566-0.jpg


Ah yes I can see where you think kids would be confused, they look absolutely %100 nothing alike...
:rolleyes:

Maybe they should have used the original Mickey Mouse that way everyone could recognize him.
main-qimg-d05a73bc0be10be8846cd59e3fffc5d1-c


He's even hip and cool to relate to the kids...
7c687533b22912d5e6f7eaa484984d0a.jpg


I love the new shorts! The wackiness and, dare I say it, animation of the new style will fit this ride perfectly!

But please never ever bring back these nightmare induces!
desktop-1423497338.jpg

Ha! Pick and choose, much?

Why, when you were choosing a pic of Mickey from the new shorts, didn't you choose something more like this:

mickey-ss4.jpg


Because that would have gone directly against your point they don't look much different. Or how about this hot mess:

latest

Goofy is HORRIBLE.

The art I posted above isn't TIMELESS. It's trendy. It's a mistake. The shorts are fine. But they could have easily happened with the characters we already know. I didn't need a Ren and Stimpy version. And for this to be what Mickey gets in the first park attraction dedicated to him is crazytown. Completely nuts.

The art in this ride won't age well. It will end up being DHS's version of Ellen's Energy Adventure. IMO.
 

Rodan75

Well-Known Member
Ha! Pick and choose, much?

Why, when you were choosing a pic of Mickey from the new shorts, didn't you choose something more like this:

mickey-ss4.jpg


Because that would have gone directly against your point they don't look much different. Or how about this hot mess:

latest

Goofy is HORRIBLE.

The art I posted above isn't TIMELESS. It's trendy. It's a mistake. The shorts are fine. But they could have easily happened with the characters we already know. I didn't need a Ren and Stimpy version. And for this to be what Mickey gets in the first park attraction dedicated to him is crazytown. Completely nuts.

The art in this ride won't age well. It will end up being DHS's version of Ellen's Energy Adventure. IMO.

Even the original shorts aren't Timeless. They are very much a product of their time. These new shorts are a product of their time.

This whole discussion is 100% subjective. There was never a right answer to it. In a few years or maybe a decade their will be an entirely new version of Mickey Mouse that is a product of its time and then someone can say that this 2013-2020 version of Mickey was classic and iconic.

I don't understand why folks who appreciate the new shorts have to be proven wrong. I love the new shorts and appreciate what they are doing and I love the old shorts (primarily because they are expressions of art from their respective decades). My appreciation for the new shorts does not attack or change your love of the older Mickey styles.

It is perfectly acceptable to have a favorite Mickey and to dislike other interpretations, it really isn't acceptable to think that your favorite Mickey has to be enforced across all generations forever.
 

Buried20KLeague

Well-Known Member
Even the original shorts aren't Timeless. They are very much a product of their time. These new shorts are a product of their time.

This whole discussion is 100% subjective. There was never a right answer to it. In a few years or maybe a decade their will be an entirely new version of Mickey Mouse that is a product of its time and then someone can say that this 2013-2020 version of Mickey was classic and iconic.

I don't understand why folks who appreciate the new shorts have to be proven wrong. I love the new shorts and appreciate what they are doing and I love the old shorts (primarily because they are expressions of art from their respective decades). My appreciation for the new shorts does not attack or change your love of the older Mickey styles.

It is perfectly acceptable to have a favorite Mickey and to dislike other interpretations, it really isn't acceptable to think that your favorite Mickey has to be enforced across all generations forever.

Since the early 30's (so close to 90 years, which means since 95% of the people on this planet have been alive), Mickey has had a very similar look. Slight tweaks and clothing style not withstanding.

gambia-_814-mickey_1.jpg


Then we have the jarring "out of left field" design in these new shorts.

You act as if he's been reinvented every decade, and this is just another routine change. That's simply not true. He's had ever so slight changes and nothing more.

Then this.

And again... That's fine. The shorts are fine. But here is Mickey's first ride centered around him. And they leave 80 something years in the dust for it. I'm simply saying I don't understand it, and I don't like it.

I'm excited for the ride... The tech sounds cool. But I'm not going to like the art style. That's all I'm saying.

It makes no sense to me, at a resort with literally tens of thousands of references to the classic Mickey we've all known our whole lives, that there would be this one, single, solitary island in the middle that completely contradicts every single thing around it.
 

Haymarket2008

Well-Known Member
I love the new shorts and design. I have no issue with them building an attraction around it. Admittedly, I wish they had given us a wider breadth of Mickey’s. I wanted to experience Sorcerer Mickey and Steamboat Willie. But alas, this is what we are getting and it looks pretty darn spectacular. It’s shaping up to be a modern classic, especially from the info we have received from insiders. Something that cannot be said for almost anything at WDW in the past 10-15 years, (FoP aside).
 

MisterPenguin

President of Animal Kingdom
Premium Member
Since the early 30's (so close to 90 years, which means since 95% of the people on this planet have been alive), Mickey has had a very similar look. Slight tweaks and clothing style not withstanding.

gambia-_814-mickey_1.jpg


Then we have the jarring "out of left field" design in these new shorts.

You act as if he's been reinvented every decade, and this is just another routine change. That's simply not true. He's had ever so slight changes and nothing more.

Then this.

And again... That's fine. The shorts are fine. But here is Mickey's first ride centered around him. And they leave 80 something years in the dust for it. I'm simply saying I don't understand it, and I don't like it.

I'm excited for the ride... The tech sounds cool. But I'm not going to like the art style. That's all I'm saying.

It makes no sense to me, at a resort with literally tens of thousands of references to the classic Mickey we've all known our whole lives, that there would be this one, single, solitary island in the middle that completely contradicts every single thing around it.

Posting sanitized versions of historical Mickeys completely undermines your awareness of the issue. And that you don't read the thread.

1530562269435.png
 

brb1006

Well-Known Member
Ha! Pick and choose, much?

Why, when you were choosing a pic of Mickey from the new shorts, didn't you choose something more like this:

mickey-ss4.jpg


Because that would have gone directly against your point they don't look much different. Or how about this hot mess:

latest

Goofy is HORRIBLE.

The art I posted above isn't TIMELESS. It's trendy. It's a mistake. The shorts are fine. But they could have easily happened with the characters we already know. I didn't need a Ren and Stimpy version. And for this to be what Mickey gets in the first park attraction dedicated to him is crazytown. Completely nuts.

The art in this ride won't age well. It will end up being DHS's version of Ellen's Energy Adventure. IMO.
Did you see the newer shorts? They toned some of that stuff down.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom