Just re-read these, and decided to quote them. It's been almost a year and my reaction is even stronger. Every superhero film so far this year (OK, the ones I saw: Superman v. Batman and Captain America: Civil War) were overbearingly long on whether the superheroes should be reigned in by government, and treated like vigilantes. You know, OK, that is an interesting concept (whether people should take justice into their own hands), but it just does seem like we might need to remember that it is a SUPERHERO movie, for goodness sakes! We have taken a fantasy approach and yet somehow trying to drag it down through the mud of reality. And it seems consistent with the "everything has to be dark" and "no Hollywood ending" approach.
Entertainment Weekly recently write about the spate of TV series endings that bent over backward to be "clever" or "unsettled," and many people I knew who watched "Nashville" on ABC complained over the last two years that the drama was little much. I constantly saw comments like "can't they be happy for at least a little while?" This mattered because the show was a great mix of music, entertainment, and a look into the lives of the songwriting community that is unique to Nashville. I know some of them. Yes, drama exists, but many are happily married (as is Chuck Esten, who played Deacon). My point being that so much entertainment these days seems to be written from what writers THINK people want rather than the reflection of real life -- love, empathy, pathos, and celebration -- with a bent toward inspiration for good measure as most of the classics actually understood. Mary Poppins was clearly that. It was fun and inspirational. It recognized the dark things but underscored the hope and inspiration.
Does everything need to be hopeful and inspirational? No, but neither do they need to be dark and deconstructionist.
I hope the new Poppins lives up to the hopefulness and fun, even with a touch of darkness, that propelled the original.
(And, yes, I hope "Nashville" comes back... and lets the people be happy some... and focuses more on the music and frenetic energy of the music industry.)