Live-Action ‘Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs’

Status
Not open for further replies.

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member
I assume the characters chosen in Snow White were dwarves because they are short and stocky and work fit the job.
The animated dwarfs were also portrayed as little men. Unfortunately, the conflation is very well established and not just a matter of casting.
 

Disney Analyst

Well-Known Member
I'll let @Disney Analyst comment on his own post just so its clear on his intent.

But this is the issue with making assumptions based on incomplete and possibly incorrect information. If you had watched the trailer you'd know more on what the movie will actually feature.

Everything is based on speculation, people who claim to know something saying something.

The details I saw floating around were that the Prince was a thief / bandit of sorts, with his 7 bandit friends. An attempt to flesh him out a bit more, and give him a quirky similarity to snow? Some sort of parallels between the two groups?

Of course. Who knows. Maybe he’s just a prince now? Maybe he’s always been a prince, but a Robin Hood sentiment?

Maybe the 7 friends were replacements for the dwarfs. Maybe they never were meant to be.

Who knows. What we know is what we have been shown.
 

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member
Everything is based on speculation, people who claim to know something saying something.

The details I saw floating around were that the Prince was a thief / bandit of sorts, with his 7 bandit friends. An attempt to flesh him out a bit more, and give him a quirky similarity to snow? Some sort of parallels between the two groups?

Of course. Who knows. Maybe he’s just a prince now? Maybe he’s always been a prince, but a Robin Hood sentiment?

Maybe the 7 friends were replacements for the dwarfs. Maybe they never were meant to be.

Who knows. What we know is what we have been shown.
I can’t vouch for their authenticity, but there were (positive) reports of early screenings that stated that the dwarfs had been replaced with bandits. Assuming these reports weren’t fabricated, the idea that the dwarfs were a later addition isn’t entirely baseless.
 

Disney Analyst

Well-Known Member
I can’t vouch for their authenticity, but there were (positive) reports of early screenings that stated that the dwarfs had been replaced with bandits. Assuming these reports weren’t fabricated, the idea that the dwarfs were a later addition isn’t entirely baseless.

Right, I’m not here to say it’s not possible.

But I also have a hard time believing much of anything, unless it’s coming from a reputable source.
 

Chi84

Premium Member
I can’t vouch for their authenticity, but there were (positive) reports of early screenings that stated that the dwarfs had been replaced with bandits. Assuming these reports weren’t fabricated, the idea that the dwarfs were a later addition isn’t entirely baseless.
Positive reports from whom?
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I can’t vouch for their authenticity, but there were (positive) reports of early screenings that stated that the dwarfs had been replaced with bandits. Assuming these reports weren’t fabricated, the idea that the dwarfs were a later addition isn’t entirely baseless.
I'm curious where did you see that, because all the reports of early screenings that I've seen just comments on Rachel's, Gal's, and Andrew's performances, nothing on the content of the story or the dwarfs.
 

Vegas Disney Fan

Well-Known Member
I'm curious where did you see that, because all the reports of early screenings that I've seen just comments on Rachel's, Gal's, and Andrew's performances, nothing on the content of the story or the dwarfs.
I did a google search and received a lot of search results, they all seem to be based of a disinsider article and a couple of tweets though so who knows if there’s any truth to any of it.

The articles mention positive reviews of the stars but also mention that many fans are upset by Zieglers comments and the films decision to replace the dwarfs, although it doesn’t say if the screening confirmed there aren’t dwarfs, just more speculation surrounding what has become a very controversial film.
 

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I did a google search and received a lot of search results, they all seem to be based of a disinsider article and a couple of tweets though so who knows if there’s any truth to any of it.

The articles mention positive reviews of the stars but also mention that many fans are upset by Zieglers comments and the films decision to replace the dwarfs, although it doesn’t say if the screening confirmed there aren’t dwarfs, just more speculation surrounding what has become a very controversial film.
Exactly, I found the same from my search a bit earlier. So yep more speculation, so nothing to see here.
 

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member
Right, I’m not here to say it’s not possible.

But I also have a hard time believing much of anything, unless it’s coming from a reputable source. There was an active anti-Disney campaign over the last few years, and anti “woke” campaigns, and this movie was a large target for them.

When there is so much money to be made, just by spreading whatever nonsense riles people up, I become suspect. Follow the money. What did these people have to gain? Who is the audience?
The report I was thinking of (and which I just provided a link to) is really positive; it doesn’t read like a hit piece or something designed to rile people up, though anything is possible I suppose.
 
Last edited:

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member
What's funny in that same tweet is the following -



So this all but confirms even back when the "7 friends" photo came out that CGI was being used.

I was thinking more of the second post I shared (with all the screenshots). That goes so far as to praise the bandits’ face-acting.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I was thinking more of the second post I shared (with all the screenshots). That goes so far as to praise the bandits’ face-acting.
Except even the twitter account on the early screening stated, the VFX was not completed at the time of the screening, so that second post shows how incomplete the information being posted was. But that its confirmed that there would be dwarfs and they would be CGI, based on the early screening.

So again this is all assumptions based on bad and incomplete information.
 

donaldtoo

Well-Known Member
I haven’t really been keeping up with this thread, but when the original animated film was in production, it was referred to as “Disney’s Folly”, and we all know how that turned out.
This one seems have had many of its own issues during production.
Obviously, we won’t know for sure until it’s released, but I’m wondering if there may be a general consensus out there regarding the success, or not, of this film…?
 

Tha Realest

Well-Known Member
This comment has been driving me nuts. The original is not 'remarkable short'. It was the FIRST FULL LENGTH ANIMATED MOVIE EVER when it was released. No one thought you could make an animated movie that long before. The world had never seen ANYTHING like it before and it changed movies FOREVER. Is it short by 2024 standards? Duh! But back when it was released it was a remarkable achievement to make something that long.
Rant over.
This is a great point. It’s a bit of recency bias to complain the film was short. For reference, few modern animated films are that much longer than Snow White’s runtime, and falls well within the mean of WDAS output over the decades:

1723329832763.png
 

Chi84

Premium Member
This is a great point. It’s a bit of recency bias to complain the film was short. For reference, few modern animated films are that much longer than Snow White’s runtime, and falls well within the mean of WDAS output over the decades:

View attachment 807970
There is length and there is length. What I’m saying is a modern audience would not sit through 80 minutes with so little plot or action.

That’s probably more an indictment of the attention spans of current audiences than the original film, but having recently watched the original I’m confident in my opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom