HSR Coming to FLA, AKA "See I told you so"

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
:lookaroun Anyone want to test that travel time... I know a few cars have passed me around those speeds :lol:



They already have done that... from 2001 through around 2004... before the state amendment was repealed... They wanted from MCO to them, while everyone else wanted a stop over at the convention center (which Orlando / orange county paid a pretty penny for and gets a lot of traffic) If disney brings up a problem again... they will just get bypassed like the monorail in vegas does with the problem hotels... and unlike the vegas monorail... this wont fail as bad due to connecting near or at the airports :lol:

Again, not arguing that Disney now wants the project. Rather, that they will use their influence to ensure they are the priority at the onset of the project.
 

jt04

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
You're looking at the project from a macro level. Unfortunately the work is done on the micro level. You yourself said the Orlando Sentinel was unsure as to the direction the project would take once started. Again, these decisions are made at the state level, not by the US DoT, or even the President. I'm not saying it won't get done, or that I (or Disney) don't want to see it (and all of the other projects) come to fruition. But it's not as simple as a line in the State of the Union Address.

Boston studied the idea of the tunnel system for nearly 20 years. The estimates came in at around $6b (adjusted for current value). They started the dig in the early 1990's. Now, after 20 years of preparation you would think such a project defines "shovel ready." Yet it would take them almost another 20 years to finally finish the work, at a cost (again adjusted for curent value and with interest added in) of $22b. Now, I know, a much larger scale. But the proverbial devil is in the details, and will be as well with this rail project.

Just because OrSen does not know does not mean it hasn't been decided. My guess is they don't want to steal the President's thunder as he is traveling all the way to Tampa just for this project tomorrow. As I said, your being too cynical. This ain't no big dig as Florida is not Boston in any way. I'm done making the point, believe what you want.
 

kashmir

Active Member
No there is about 8 billion to go around. You might want to read the complete high speed rail thread I bumped. I explain everything, and I mean everything, as to why Florida is a GREAT choice for High Speed Rail.

Congradulations Central Florida. :sohappy:

Congratulations!
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
Just because OrSen does not know does not mean it hasn't been decided. My guess is they don't want to steal the President's thunder as he is traveling all the way to Tampa just for this project tomorrow. As I said, your being too cynical. This ain't no big dig as Florida is not Boston in any way. I'm done making the point, believe what you want.

The announcement is the thunder. The appearance is gravy. And as for the way billions of taxpaying dollars will be spent, and where; the responsibility of the press is to report it. Detail leaks happen all the time, and will not reduce by one the number of cameras and press at the announcement.

Yes, how a large government project will be implemented is easily and readily equated to cynicism.

My Lord, EP Explorer was right, logic really is kryptonite to you, isn't it?
 

jt04

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
The announcement is the thunder. The appearance is gravy. And as for the way billions of taxpaying dollars will be spent, and where; the responsibility of the press is to report it. Detail leaks happen all the time, and will not reduce by one the number of cameras and press at the announcement.

Yes, how a large government project will be implemented is easily and readily equated to cynicism.

My Lord, EP Explorer was right, logic really is kryptonite to you, isn't it?

You think the press is "responsible"? Now there is a lack of logic! :lol:

What planet have you been living on? :ROFLOL:
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
You think the press is "responsible"? Now there is a lack of logic! :lol:

What planet have you been living on? :ROFLOL:

You don't like the press? Stop referring to the Orlando Sentinel as a primary source of information. Again, try, just try, logic for once. You might even like it.....
 

Wilt Dasney

Well-Known Member
The announcement is the thunder. The appearance is gravy. And as for the way billions of taxpaying dollars will be spent, and where; the responsibility of the press is to report it. Detail leaks happen all the time, and will not reduce by one the number of cameras and press at the announcement.
I agree with you. It's nice that Obama mentioned the project, but it's really irrelevant as to whether or not it gets finished. State/local politics can be a very shortsighted and provincial exercise.

Notice that this is not a prediction that the rail will not happen; it is a statement (and I believe this is your point as well) that the involvement of the federal government really doesn't guarantee anything.

Projects like this with so many moving parts involved (Disney/Orlando/other theme park providers/Tampa/local businesses/state government/federal government/etc.) can be derailed depressingly easily, by one rogue politician or one annoyed Chamber of Commerce member. Here's hoping that doesn't happen here. It is encouraging that the project has gotten this far.
 

hrcollectibles

Active Member
Just because OrSen does not know does not mean it hasn't been decided. My guess is they don't want to steal the President's thunder as he is traveling all the way to Tampa just for this project tomorrow. As I said, your being too cynical. This ain't no big dig as Florida is not Boston in any way. I'm done making the point, believe what you want.


OrSen? Isn't that Bree Hodge's Husband on Desperate housewives?
 

tecowdw

Well-Known Member
Near Celebration. On the west side of I-4 I think.

Looking at the maps submitted by FDOT, the Disney station looks to be proposed on the west-bound side of I4 between the 192 and Osceola Parkway connections. So basically - just east of WWOS complex.
 

jt04

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
You don't like the press? Stop referring to the Orlando Sentinel as a primary source of information. Again, try, just try, logic for once. You might even like it.....

Actually, my source was me. Perhaps you need to read the thread where I explained all this over the last few months. You told me I was wrong then too. Perhaps that is your problem. You just can't stand being wrong. Sad.

Bye. :wave:
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
Yeah, that's why you referred to the "OrSen" on more than one occassion. Or did you forget the Orlando Sentinel was a newspaper....

Whatever it takes to fit the facts into your mind, I suppose....
 

jt04

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
A lot of people thought this was going to happen. You happened to be one of them, so now you think you "told people so." LOL Man, you never quit acting like a...well....nevermind.

A well informed contributor to WDWMagic?

Didn't this get approved like ... 6 months ago?

No. In fact, the complete distribution of the High Speed Rail funds has not been announced except for the Orlando-Tampa link announced just today. Here is the thread where we hashed all this out with people like " Giraffe Lounge" and "lazyboy97" and "wm49rs".

It explains everything. And much more. :lol:

http://forums.wdwmagic.com/showthread.php?t=497536
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
A well informed contributor to WDWMagic?



No. In fact, the complete distribution of the High Speed Rail funds has not been announced except for the Orlando-Tampa link announced just today. Here is the thread where we hashed all this out with people like " Giraffe Lounge" and "lazyboy97" and "wm49rs".

It explains everything. And much more. :lol:

http://forums.wdwmagic.com/showthread.php?t=497536

Actually JT, your entire argument before diverged into some rambling dissertation on how Florida would get these funds and essentially nowhere else, because of political reasons. And what you ignored then (as now), is the process. Just becaue the President is making one announcement in Tampa doesn't mean the funds are all being sent there. In fact, other rail announcements are going to be made throughout the country by members of the Obama Administration, including in California, which you said would get any money because of the way in voted in the last election.

Oh, and another thing, just because the project is "shovel ready" in your convoluted mind, doesn't mean the project is going to start right away. Try reading a newspaper outside the "OrSen" and you'll see the precise process I trying explaining to you has to be undertaken:

"Florida is well positioned, having secured most of the right of way and completing an environmental impact study. In the coming year, the project would be put out to bid and construction could begin in early 2011."

Wow, what are the odds? The State of Florida actually has to find someone to do the work for them? Go figure. I guess things don't work as neatly as you want them to Jt.

http://www.tampabay.com/news/politi...-to-tampa-for-florida-high-speed-rail/1068768
 

MousDad

New Member
Why would this announcement prompt anyone to want to apologize to jt?

And further, why would anyone actually do it, even if prompted?
 

DisneyJoe

Well-Known Member
Magical Express will be discontinued once the rail is operational IMO.

The Magical Express luggage component is a big selling point for many travelers - with HSR you would need to claim your own luggage and drag it to the train. The Disney Resort check in service for participating airlines also magically takes your luggage back to your plane when you are leaving WDW, as Magical Express takes you back to the airport.

If they did discontinue Magical Express, and travelers took their luggage on the HSR to Disney's station, Disney would need to have transport from that station to the resorts that would allow luggage to be taken onboard; current Disney transportation does not allow, and is not designed for, luggage to be transferred with the guest.
 

Pumbas Nakasak

Heading for the great escape.
If WDW gets a stop, who funds it? If I were a tax payer Id be wondering why one comercial company was being favoured over others.
 

Pumbas Nakasak

Heading for the great escape.
Why would this announcement prompt anyone to want to apologize to jt?

And further, why would anyone actually do it, even if prompted?


Because we as little people appreciate what an honour it is to receive his proclamations, guidance and vision.

Besides its not nice to mock care in the community patients
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom