I have a soft spot for HKDL. Within the context of HKDL, Small world, Jungle cruise and Iron Man are all headliners. I get that it’s hard to draw comparisons between the other parks and ‘rank’ the attractions, but that’s what they are. Functionally the pulls of their various lands. I have no aspirations that FEA needs to be considered an E ticket on the world stage either, but that is what it will be for HKDL.
This does not take away that yes HKDL deserves a functional, world stage ‘F-ticket’. I also side with SDL is still somewhat objectively a more robust park on the world stage. Though I’d never tell anyone to fly to visit either in a silo, Hong Kong I prefer over Shanghai in terms of city pairs. SDL is more impressive for a Magic Kingdom/Epcot fan.
Hopefully the new DCL Adventure does some HKDL itineraries.
I think the preference for the park comes down to one’s affinity for charm versus scale. Neither is wrong per say. They are honestly like two sides of the coin, which is kind of nice. Though SDL will continue to probably accelerate as a resort and pull more clearly in front long term.
As mentioned, neither are monolithic or copy cats. I’m very glad both exist.