Great "UP" Review

H20Babie

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
A soaring success

Filmmakers bring a light touch to poignant, funny animated adventure

By: Randall King
29/05/2009 1:00 AM


1210606.jpg
http://media.winnipegfreepress.com/images/1210606.jpg
Filmmakers bring a light touch to poignant, funny animated adventure Up. (PIXAR / DISNEY)



IN the brief history of com­puter animation, an early problem was that human characters tended to look plastic. The maverick anima­tion company Pixar brilliantly circumvented that debility with their first feature, Toy Story, in which almost all its protagonists were plastic.

It isn't as much of a problem now, given that the medium has come a long way in a short time. Even so, you have directors like McG deliberately scaling back the use of computer-generated images in the movie Terminator Salvation, claiming that it distracts from the earthy realism of footage shot in-camera.

Maybe. But then, why is there more humanity in Pixar's new, all-CG feature Up than there is in the entirety of Terminator? Also: More nuance, more tenderness and an altogether more insightful perspective on what it is to be alive.

Up wears its ambition boldly, starting with the introduction of a quiet, adventure-obsessed boy named Carl Frederickson, who meets his soul mate Ellie in an abandoned house, pretending to engage in the same kind of adventurism as their Lindbergh-like idol Charles F. Muntz (Christopher Plummer). Carl and Ellie marry, and we witness their happy lives together in a gorgeous, wordless montage, rendered poignant by their deferred dreams of adventure and their failure to conceive. (Yes, it's heavy stuff, even in the context of a children's film.)

At the end of it, Carl (Ed Asner) is alone, facing eviction from his home, and the death of his dreams altogether. But at the last minute, he conceives of an escape that will honour the wishes of the late Ellie: the former balloon salesman inflates thousands of balloons with helium, attaches them to his fireplace and flies his lonely abode to the adventure mecca of Paradise Falls in Venezuela.

Unfortunately for Carl, a stowaway "wilderness explorer" named Russell (Jordan Nagai) is on his porch when the house shakes free of its earthly bonds. By the time Carl gets to Paradise Falls, he is responsible for the kid, a giant exotic bird dubbed Kevin, and a dog named Dug (voiced by Bob Peterson, who co-directed the film with Monsters Inc. helmsman Pete Docter). Yes, that's right, voiced. Dug and all the dogs of Paradise Falls have been given the ability to speak courtesy of a high-tech collar.

Carl even gets to meet his childhood hero Muntz, only to discover that his one-time idol is not so much a crazy old coot as a malevolent madman.

Peterson and Docter pull off an awesome feat of juggling the movie's verbal comedy, action sequences and bittersweet soul, keeping it all as gravity-defying as those balloons.

And how about that killer irony at the movie's core? Carl experiences the adventure (and also the parenting) of which he always dreamed, but he is too distracted by his mission to get the house to Paradise Falls to notice. Indeed, he spends much of his time dragging his floating house across the landscape.

Sure, it's a bizarre spectacle worthy of that surrealist Luis Buñuel. But it's also as elegant a metaphor as you could wish for a man unable to let go of his past.
randall.king@freepress.mb.ca


OtherVoices

Through its writing, direction and execution, Up doesn't just achieve hipness, it transcends it. With its spirit of fun and adventure, it's a thrill ride, but a thrill ride with heart.
-- Bill Goodykoontz, Arizona Republic​

This is a wonderful film. It tells a story. The characters are as believable as any characters can be who spend much of their time floating above the rainforests of Venezuela.
-- Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times​

Extending the patented Pixar mix of humour and heart, Up is the studio's most deeply emotional and affecting work.
-- Richard Corliss, Time magazine​

As of May, Best Picture of the Year: Another jewel in Pixar's crown, Up is a truly uplifting experience, a thematically inventive, emotionally touching, poignantly romantic film that lingers in memory long after seeing it.
-- Emanuel Levy, emanuellevy.com​

The look of Up is a world away from Pixar's usual CGI intricacies -- simple in a way that only artists with a genius for complexity can achieve.
-- David Edelstein, New York magazine​

As buoyant and richly tinted as the balloons that figure so prominently in its story, Up is also thoroughly grounded in real emotion and ideas of substance.
-- Lisa Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly​

A feather-light farce with a delicious dose of the sentimental, it isn't the animation company's biggest, most complicated or even its best. It's just a film in which most every oddball element of an odd yet familiar story works.
-- Roger Moore, Orlando Sentinel​

Rest assured, it gets funny. And it's thrilling, too, as the third act takes place almost entirely in the sky.
-- Robert Wilonsky, Village Voice​

-- Compiled by Canwest News Service
 

glendroid

Active Member
i just saw it a couple hours ago!

all i can say is it is FANTASTIC!


they should make an UP attraction such as a flying house simulator =O
 

kitten2299

New Member
Just came from seeing it My parents took me and my daughter and we LOVED it!!! But why did they have to have a trailer for toy Story 3 since it doesnt come out for a year now that is all my daughter is going to ask to see! I would of rather seen a trailer for A Christmas Carol! Hope everyone enjoyed it as much as my family!
 

Exprcoofto

New Member
Just came back form seeing it in 3D about 20 min ago. This was another brilliant Pixar film! I saw Bolt in 3D and it just made me extremely dizzy, however, this was not the case in UP. The 3D is mild - yet they use it well during specific scenes.

Great scenes, great music, great characters, great storyline. My second favorite Pixar film! :sohappy:
 

Erika

Moderator
I can't wait to see this one! I want to take my daughter-- so glad to read/hear all the great reviews it's getting because the trailer looked very promising.
 

Tiggerfanatic

Well-Known Member
Just got home from the theater - absolutely loved this movie! My theater didn't have 3D, so can't comment on those effects. The short before the movie made me laugh out loud, too. We saw the trailer for the Princess and the Frog coming out @ Christmas.
 

KeithVH

Well-Known Member
Just got home from the theater - absolutely loved this movie! My theater didn't have 3D, so can't comment on those effects. The short before the movie made me laugh out loud, too. We saw the trailer for the Princess and the Frog coming out @ Christmas.

Did you feel that your experience w/o 3D affected your enjoyment of the movie? My girls went to the first showing today and it was 3D and they raved about it. Me, I hate those glasses (yes, I grudgingly put up with it for Philharmagic).:animwink:
 

Tiggerfanatic

Well-Known Member
Did you feel that your experience w/o 3D affected your enjoyment of the movie? My girls went to the first showing today and it was 3D and they raved about it. Me, I hate those glasses (yes, I grudgingly put up with it for Philharmagic).:animwink:


No, not at all. And I was actually glad that I didn't have to wear those glasses for 2 hours - with my astigmatism, I would have been ready to hurl and had a raging headache by the end of the movie. I can wear them for short periods like Philharmagic, but even that is pushing it sometimes.
 

Disneyfanman

Well-Known Member
The movie is sweet, beautiful to watch, and laugh out loud funny. I can't believe they pulled this off. An old crabby man, young kid, and a couple of the funniest animal characters that I have ever seen make it an absolute delight. I was worried that my cynical 16 year old wouldn't enjoy the story but no worries. As for 3-D, some of the early reviews from Cannes said that it was just as enjoyable n 2-D so I skipped the extra $$ on this one. No problem. I still loved the film.
 

hoping4nash

New Member
I've been reading this board for years, but I have never felt prompted to post before now. I saw Up yesterday with a fellow Disney lover. The previews had made me a bit skeptical, but the movie absolutely blew me away. In fact, I want to go see it again as soon as possible. There were definitely moments in there that made me cry (and considering that yesterday was my last day of high school and that didn't make me cry but Up did, that's saying something). The whole thing was amazing, and it just became one of my favorite Pixar movies.
 

DisneyPrincess5

Well-Known Member
I've been reading this board for years, but I have never felt prompted to post before now. I saw Up yesterday with a fellow Disney lover. The previews had made me a bit skeptical, but the movie absolutely blew me away. In fact, I want to go see it again as soon as possible. There were definitely moments in there that made me cry (and considering that yesterday was my last day of high school and that didn't make me cry but Up did, that's saying something). The whole thing was amazing, and it just became one of my favorite Pixar movies.

Glad you enjoyed it and welcome to the boards!
 

Captain Hank

Well-Known Member
I saw it yesterday. ABSOLUTELY OUTSTANDING. I had extremely high expectations going in, and was really afraid that I'd be let down. Well, I liked it even better than I thought I would. I never cry at movies, but I got choked up during the opening montage where we see Carl and Ellie's life progress. Funny, emotional and adventuous all in one. By the way, I saw it in 3-D, and I thought the effects did add something to the movie. However, I think it would be just as enjoyable in 2-D.
 

sjead

New Member
We just got back from seeing Up and all I can say is WOW!! It was truly amazing. . . thought provoking, heart wrenching, funny, kind, etc. Our theater did not offer it in 3D but I thouorghly enjoyed the 2D version. Enthusiastic thumbs up from the whole family!! I hope this movie gets integrated into the parks somehow. We also enjoyed the short. . . what a cute concept!
 

EpcotServo

Well-Known Member
Seen in 3-D and traditional, and this movie is beyond special. It's one of the true testaments to the art, beauty, and soul of Animation that continues to be often mistreated and neglected by this country and it's people.

I believe that these ten films created by Pixar are a catalog that will continue to entertain and be cherished, as all great stories should be. And as always, I couldn't be more proud of every single awesome person that works at Pixar.
:D
 

hwdelien

Member
Just took the family. Kids aged 3-13 and my wife 33 and myself 42. Everyone of us enjoyed it. We spent the extra $3 for the 3D version and it was nice, but I'm not sure it was necessary. The characters were great. I have to admit the kids got bored during the charming video of the couples life together and my three year old dozed off. Once the house went UP everyone was enjoying it. The dogs with voices were hillarious and had the entire theater laughing especially the doberman with the short in his collar. I can't wait for it to come out on DVD.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom