Future Star Wars Story movies put on hold thanks to SOLO

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
Well..now that makes you a “butt hurt old fart”...

Which is just stupid...unless some 25 year fool borrowing $200,000 for a psychology degree is gonna shell out what I have for Star Wars...and Disney for that matter...

Then pipe down and let the big kids talk. Keyboard rambos without a pot to pee in making fun of the most loyal fan base ever with the most successful franchise at the bank doesn’t equate. The Rock had a saying about that...
woah woah, I think you need to chill out. I was on your side. I was also stating the difference in Star wars to other franchises. Unless I mistook your humor, maybe you should take your pills that keep your personalities in check.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
woah woah, I think you need to chill out. I was on your side. I was also stating the difference in Star wars to other franchises. Unless I mistook your humor, maybe you should take your pills that keep your personalities in check.

Yep...it was sarcastic...hence the quotes.

The thing about young fans lecturing out of turn...sadly that’s real. In every “discussion” about Star Wars.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I think that's where episode 7 succeeded. Yes I liked it, and I think the reason some people didn't (not all people who disliked it but a majority), they wanted a whole new story.
Well if you look a formula for a trilogy..
ep1 introduce characters.. give us a reason to care
eps put the good guys in jeopardy
ep3 good guys win

episode 7 did that while.... also giving us that feel good that made us forget we got prequels instead of 789 when they should have happened. While introducing the new characters. Basically heres your security blanket.... heres some new toys to play with.
Episode 8 is where we should have got peril, this is why killing snoke was dumb because nobody fears kylo, even though theres what 8 people left of the good guys... we don't feel they are in peril?
Episode 9... I don't even care about it (the trailer might change this..) but right now there is no reason for an episode 9.. wheres your cliff hanger....wheres the heroes in jeopardy.
that's not star wars.. that's simple story telling.

Well I agree with your first point, EP7 did succeed at playing into the fans nostalgia factor. But the rest is where I disagree.

Snoke in my opinion wasn't that compelling of a character anyways. The inner turmoil of Kylo trying to live up to his grandfather evil side was a more compelling story. And that is where I think EP8 was trying to focus on, instead of Snoke. And really I have a feeling if Snoke is the all powerful being that fans thought he was anyways, he'll be back in EP9.

I mentioned this in another thread in a conversation with sirwalter. But EP8 left us with the question how are so few going to overcome the insurmountable odds against them to beat the First Order. Its the classic David Vs. Goliath storytelling device. That is your cliff hanger. Add that to Rey having the Jedi texts and what she will do with them. And you have plenty to look forward to in EP9.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
...I deal in science. It’s how I mathematically determined that a Brazil pavilion in Epcot isn’t going to happen because the PCQ is 98.716%

Math was never my strong suit, even though I'm a fairly analytical person. But I do look at things with a business sense (as you can tell) and from a pragmatic sensibility (as you rightly indicated) while throwing in some fandom for good measure.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
You know...

I’ve been thinking that the whole modern movie angle may in fact be wrong.

There was this idea that you have to bring in the kids...kids are everything...

But what if the “peter pan” demographic is the goal? People live into their 90’s...people work longer...they have way more ready entertainment and obsession with it in a relatively frivolous world. And 60 is kinda the new 40...

Maybe Star Wars is all wrong because it should be specifically targeted at the immature, but still adult, Fan boy?

They bring their kids, and grandkids...and it would have still stuck?

In that case...Lucas really screwed it up...but disney is too. You don’t crap on Luke, kill Han, relabel the teams and redefine the force...

No sir, Johnny.

Just an idea
 

Tony the Tigger

Well-Known Member
You can’t look at Solo as a best effort.

If Harrison Ford wasn’t so over it right now and would have been involved at all, I guarantee you it would have done much better. He could have narrated, been in some scenes, etc. Bingo, box office bucks.

Plan B: If they cast someone well known in the role of Han, it would have done much better also.

It didn’t underperform because of fanboycotts or fatigue. There wasn’t a big enough draw beyond a character’s name, and how he met Chewie.
 

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
Well I agree with your first point, EP7 did succeed at playing into the fans nostalgia factor. But the rest is where I disagree.

Snoke in my opinion wasn't that compelling of a character anyways. The inner turmoil of Kylo trying to live up to his grandfather evil side was a more compelling story. And that is where I think EP8 was trying to focus on, instead of Snoke. And really I have a feeling if Snoke is the all powerful being that fans thought he was anyways, he'll be back in EP9.

I mentioned this in another thread in a conversation with sirwalter. But EP8 left us with the question how are so few going to overcome the insurmountable odds against them to beat the First Order. Its the classic David Vs. Goliath storytelling device. That is your cliff hanger. Add that to Rey having the Jedi texts and what she will do with them. And you have plenty to look forward to in EP9.
But the first order seems like a joke... you have all of this power and this might and you make boneheaded mistakes continuously.. it feels like the keystone cops. I mean the first 2 death stars seemed plausible... but like 8 people just destroyed your two biggest ships and you have this huge cannon and all of the new ATATs and people sneak out the back... the whole movie should have ended in the first few scenes when they were blowing the ships up as they left.. or at the end when they landed...
So the first order doesn't scare me the way the empire did (even though they were bumbling... it felt like darth was just there too late or the good guys just escaped.. darth was scary
Kylo in 7 seemed to be all about his grandfather (another plus for episode 7) they dumped that in 8.. "let the past die" he dumps his mask and you don't get that he cares about his bloodline any more.
If we had gotten black/white Anakin like the rumors from 7 and 8 I think 8 could have been twice as good.. and id be more excited for 8 appears to rey as Anakin that's sorry for his mistakes and wants to guide her..... evil Anakin/darth who hates everything good and wants kylo to "finish what he started". He could be talking to them both.. and at the end luke could have helped Anakin resolve his inner battle. Or rey or kylo... maybe kylo kills luke and that makes Anakin totally good and he convinces kylo to turn good... who knows.. but id love to see that story AND it would tie the new trilogy to all the other movies and finish this 9 episode saga.
anakin-force-ghost.png
 

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
You can’t look at Solo as a best effort.

If Harrison Ford wasn’t so over it right now and would have been involved at all, I guarantee you it would have done much better. He could have narrated, been in some scenes, etc. Bingo, box office bucks.

Plan B: If they cast someone well known in the role of Han, it would have done much better also.

It didn’t underperform because of fanboycotts or fatigue. There wasn’t a big enough draw beyond a character’s name, and how he met Chewie.
that's funny... I had mentioned to someone months ago he should narrate... I still liked the movie they made though. I looked at it as a book you would read between movies.. it tells the story you don't get in the movies... and your imagination fills in the faces and gaps
 

erasure fan1

Well-Known Member
It didn’t underperform because of fanboycotts or fatigue. There wasn’t a big enough draw beyond a character’s name, and how he met Chewie.
You are right on about fatigue, it had zero to do with it. Now the boycotts in my opinion did hurt the movie more than some might think. The boycotts spread the seeds of doubt and that is what the media was focused on. In turn all the casual fan kept hearing was the negative, prompting them to stay away. Trust me, I know it's not the only thing, but I don't believe for a second that it wasn't a factor. Disney/Lucasfilm dropped just about every ball you could on this one.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
But the first order seems like a joke... you have all of this power and this might and you make boneheaded mistakes continuously.. it feels like the keystone cops. I mean the first 2 death stars seemed plausible... but like 8 people just destroyed your two biggest ships and you have this huge cannon and all of the new ATATs and people sneak out the back... the whole movie should have ended in the first few scenes when they were blowing the ships up as they left.. or at the end when they landed...
So the first order doesn't scare me the way the empire did (even though they were bumbling... it felt like darth was just there too late or the good guys just escaped.. darth was scary
Kylo in 7 seemed to be all about his grandfather (another plus for episode 7) they dumped that in 8.. "let the past die" he dumps his mask and you don't get that he cares about his bloodline any more.
If we had gotten black/white Anakin like the rumors from 7 and 8 I think 8 could have been twice as good.. and id be more excited for 8 appears to rey as Anakin that's sorry for his mistakes and wants to guide her..... evil Anakin/darth who hates everything good and wants kylo to "finish what he started". He could be talking to them both.. and at the end luke could have helped Anakin resolve his inner battle. Or rey or kylo... maybe kylo kills luke and that makes Anakin totally good and he convinces kylo to turn good... who knows.. but id love to see that story AND it would tie the new trilogy to all the other movies and finish this 9 episode saga.
anakin-force-ghost.png

That is the fanboy in you talking. And I get it. But that is the issue with most SW fans, they build up this story in their head of what SW is suppose to be. Building up their own stories on how a particular story should have been, just like you did. When in reality fans don't own the universe or the stories, except the ones in our heads.

I don't see how the First Order and its issues is any different than the Empire and its issues. The empire only seemed scarier because you were a kid. As an adult its successor just doesn't seem scary. But when you think about it, they are exactly the same. They are both evil regimes trying to have their thumb on the galaxy.

The let the past die, it was Kylo basically saying I can't live in the shadow of my grandfather anymore. I have to be my own man and forge my own destiny. But you can tell he still has inner turmoil about it.

For right or wrong Johnson was trying to tell a story that was beyond the Skywalker saga trying to lead it into the future. Basically that is what the lines were for, "Let the past die", "The Jedi must die", etc. Trying to say that the SW universe is bigger than just this one single family bloodline. I see where he was trying to go, and I appreciate it. Maybe he went about it in the wrong way, but I can appreciate what he was trying to do. Because at some point you can't just have Skywalker stories. I know a lot of fans don't like that and aren't comfortable with it. But its the nature of life, things must die.

I'm looking to see how it finishes out in EP9.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
that's funny... I had mentioned to someone months ago he should narrate... I still liked the movie they made though. I looked at it as a book you would read between movies.. it tells the story you don't get in the movies... and your imagination fills in the faces and gaps

He would have wanted a fortune. He made those stupid jokes about “I got paid” when the force awakens came out...but ultimately That’s all that mattered. He and Lucas seemed to be the most crotchety old men in Hollywood.

He reportedly got $25 plus a piece that pushed it to $50ish for an exit movie...I think hamill and fisher got like 2 each.
 
Last edited:

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
The problem with telling the story “beyond the skywalker story”...is if you were gonna try to capitalize off the skywalker Story...you were gonna fail.

You could/should have done intros to new characters and If done well; let them take the stage after. And had the old ones go out blazing. They did the opposite...stupid deaths...except the one that should be dead...and 4 “new” characters that might amount to 1.5.

Tire fire from a management/legacy standpoint.
 

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
That is the fanboy in you talking. And I get it. But that is the issue with most SW fans, they build up this story in their head of what SW is suppose to be. Building up their own stories on how a particular story should have been, just like you did. When in reality fans don't own the universe or the stories, except the ones in our heads.

I don't see how the First Order and its issues is any different than the Empire and its issues. The empire only seemed scarier because you were a kid. As an adult its successor just doesn't seem scary. But when you think about it, they are exactly the same. They are both evil regimes trying to have their thumb on the galaxy.

The let the past die, it was Kylo basically saying I can't live in the shadow of my grandfather anymore. I have to be my own man and forge my own destiny. But you can tell he still has inner turmoil about it.

For right or wrong Johnson was trying to tell a story that was beyond the Skywalker saga trying to lead it into the future. Basically that is what the lines were for, "Let the past die", "The Jedi must die", etc. Trying to say that the SW universe is bigger than just this one single family bloodline. I see where he was trying to go, and I appreciate it. Maybe he went about it in the wrong way, but I can appreciate what he was trying to do. Because at some point you can't just have Skywalker stories. I know a lot of fans don't like that and aren't comfortable with it. But its the nature of life, things must die.

I'm looking to see how it finishes out in EP9.
I'm not looking at it as a fan boy. Although I will say darth isn't as scary after the prequels, but you could tell he was super powerful... what ive noticed as an adult though is how little respect he got from the empire. Kylo is just a brat that ive yet to see him really beat anybody... some guards with Reys help? Of course we didnt see Darth ever do much until rogue one, but that was because of the effects that were possible at the time, and lucas saw it more like sword fighting and errol Flynn or zoro style movies, than what it became later. You say Rian Johnson wanted to show more of the universe I ask you .. Did he? I mean we see canto bight, but nothing besides that (an abandoned salt base doesn't really count). I would have loved some side stories of other worlds characters, I didn't feel that. In fact we prob met less new characters and worlds than any other star wars movie. I think Rian threw away everything Darth vader outside of snoke making fun of kylo. Rian did a disservice to star wars, yes it wasn't the movie I wanted but I was open to any story as long as it drove the story somewhere... IN MY OPINION it didn't drive the story anywhere just ended interesting arcs. What new character did we get? What new struggle did we get? What did we lose?
Caretakers
Rose
holdo
dj
porgs
outside of rose none of them will be back.. maybe dj.. but I doubt it

episode 7
Maz Kanata could have been featured more, to me this is someone needed more explained.. maybe ep 9 or the comics.
Captain Phasma was a waste but jj screwed that up as well (boba fett for the new trilogy I guess) great toy.. not great in the movies
snoke.. killed off... we disagree on his importance
kylo, rey, hux, finn, knights of ren

I too am ready for 9... right now I'm on a level 5... after the first trailer I'm sure ill be at an 8 ... hopefully they give us a reason in the trailers to go see it. I will say the last 2 movies the trailers have made you ready to see them.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I'm not looking at it as a fan boy. Although I will say darth isn't as scary after the prequels, but you could tell he was super powerful... what ive noticed as an adult though is how little respect he got from the empire. Kylo is just a brat that ive yet to see him really beat anybody... some guards with Reys help? Of course we didnt see Darth ever do much until rogue one, but that was because of the effects that were possible at the time, and lucas saw it more like sword fighting and errol Flynn or zoro style movies, than what it became later. You say Rian Johnson wanted to show more of the universe I ask you .. Did he? I mean we see canto bight, but nothing besides that (an abandoned salt base doesn't really count). I would have loved some side stories of other worlds characters, I didn't feel that. In fact we prob met less new characters and worlds than any other star wars movie. I think Rian threw away everything Darth vader outside of snoke making fun of kylo. Rian did a disservice to star wars, yes it wasn't the movie I wanted but I was open to any story as long as it drove the story somewhere... IN MY OPINION it didn't drive the story anywhere just ended interesting arcs. What new character did we get? What new struggle did we get? What did we lose?
Caretakers
Rose
holdo
dj
porgs
outside of rose none of them will be back.. maybe dj.. but I doubt it

episode 7
Maz Kanata could have been featured more, to me this is someone needed more explained.. maybe ep 9 or the comics.
Captain Phasma was a waste but jj screwed that up as well (boba fett for the new trilogy I guess) great toy.. not great in the movies
snoke.. killed off... we disagree on his importance
kylo, rey, hux, finn, knights of ren

I too am ready for 9... right now I'm on a level 5... after the first trailer I'm sure ill be at an 8 ... hopefully they give us a reason in the trailers to go see it. I will say the last 2 movies the trailers have made you ready to see them.

We just see it from different perspectives, which is what is good about films. Everyone brings their own experiences and thoughts into the film that we all see what we want. We all catch different things.

You see a snotty brat in Kylo. I see a young man who was mentally tricked into trying to live up to the image of his family blood line. That is why I didn't find Snoke all that compelling, basically using the same mental tricks Palpatine used on Anakin. Kylo being tormented with the inner struggle of trying to live up to his grandfather's legacy while still trying to cling to bit of the light left in him. Is he brought back to the light, or grey if what I believe happens with Rey happens. Or does he dive head first into the dark side and ultimately is destroyed by it. That is the more compelling story to me, than anything they could have done with Snoke.
 

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
We just see it from different perspectives, which is what is good about films. Everyone brings their own experiences and thoughts into the film that we all see what we want. We all catch different things.

You see a snotty brat in Kylo. I see a young man who was mentally tricked into trying to live up to the image of his family blood line. That is why I didn't find Snoke all that compelling, basically using the same mental tricks Palpatine used on Anakin. Kylo being tormented with the inner struggle of trying to live up to his grandfather's legacy while still trying to cling to bit of the light left in him. Is he brought back to the light, or grey if what I believe happens with Rey happens. Or does he dive head first into the dark side and ultimately is destroyed by it. That is the more compelling story to me, than anything they could have done with Snoke.
Although I doubt we will ever get clarification unless they make a snoke comic or movie some day (btw I don't read the comics). Was snoke using Darths helmet to speak to kylo. In Ep.7 he clearly acts like the helmet or a spirit has talked to him in the past... was this snoke. Anyhoo... off to Disney ride threads.
 

Mmoore29

Well-Known Member
Kathleen Kennedy is not going anywhere. Rian Johnson is not going anywhere. And the rumors of "postponing the anthology films" are just speculation, the usual "sources tell us that" crap from the supermarket tabloids. You can't put any faith in that whatsoever. The one thing that is likely going to change is that Disney is coming to realize "Hey, Star Wars is not the MCU, and we shouldn't treat it like it is anymore. Maybe we should space out our release schedule a bit more, and not do one film a year anymore."

Oh, and to the person from way back. I'm not here to push a narrative. I'm not here with a victim mentality or "forcing issues at someone." I'm simply here because I love Star Wars and I love what Disney has done, storywise, and I am confident in how it will turn out. I'm just here to lay the facts out, and know that hopefully, someone will recognize that all the backlash reports and "demise" comments are wildly overblown. You know, being jaded and cynical really isn't worth it, and it gets you nowhere, truly. I easily could be, but I'm an incurable optimist at heart.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom