Disney's Live Action The Little Mermaid

BuddyThomas

Well-Known Member
Exactly. Any time black people step into roles that white people think should be reserved for only white actors, which tend to be fantasy roles, mind you, they lose their minds and troll. We saw it with Star Wars, we’re seeing it now with Lord of the Rings, House of the Dragon, Pinocchio, and The Little Mermaid. It happens all the time.

Mermaid’s full trailer hasn’t even come out yet.
Also, I wonder if AMC's new INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE series is also getting trolled because Louis, the character previously played by Brad Pitt, is now played by Jacob Anderson, an African American actor. I wonder if they think vampires are not allowed to be black, or if it is limited to mermaids.
 

Mr Ferret 75

Thank you sir. You were an inspiration.
Premium Member
Also, I wonder if AMC's new INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE series is also getting trolled because Louis, the character previously played by Brad Pitt, is now played by Jacob Anderson, an African American actor. I wonder if they think vampires are not allowed to be black, or if it is limited to mermaids.
sunglasses deal with it GIF by BBQ Films
 

Californian Elitist

Well-Known Member
Also, I wonder if AMC's new INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE series is also getting trolled because Louis, the character previously played by Brad Pitt, is now played by Jacob Anderson, an African American actor. I wonder if they think vampires are not allowed to be black, or if it is limited to mermaids.
I actually had no clue an Interview with the
Vampire series was in development! How interesting, I will look into this. I love the movie.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

BuddyThomas

Well-Known Member
, but as previously stated, mermaids do not exist and can look like anything the filmmakers want them to look like. Also, I hate to break it to you, but there was already an Asian American Ariel in the Disney stage version. All the usual suspects had their panties in a bunch over that one too.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

CaptainAmerica

Premium Member
If this isn't enough for people to see how important this is-I don't know what is
That's exactly how my white daughters reacted to the trailer. Little girls love mermaids.

To reiterate, since I know not every person reads every post, I have no problem with this casting. But that doesn't mean it's "important." In fact, the argument up until this point has been the opposite, that it shouldn't matter what race or nationality she is, an argument that I agree with.

Position 1: "It's important that she's white." <--- Racist people say this.
Position 2: "It doesn't matter what race she is." <--- We were here. This is the consensus mainstream opinion.
Position 3: "It's important that she's Black." <--- But you moved the goalpasts to here. This is where you get backlash.
 
Last edited:

DKampy

Well-Known Member
The difference is these so-called “anti-woke” people seem to obsess over things they say they can’t stand…how many different ways can they say “ Rings of Power” is woke… if I don’t like something I say it is not for me and move on… I am more inclined to go on and on about something I loved.
 

itsy bitsy spider

Well-Known Member
The difference is these so-called “anti-woke” people seem to obsess over things they say they can’t stand…how many different ways can they say “ Rings of Power” is woke… if I don’t like something I say it is not for me and move on… I am more inclined to go on and on about something I loved.

You're just like the "anti-woke" mob, but you're on the other side. So you saying this stuff is like "The Pot calling the Kettle black."
 

GimpYancIent

Well-Known Member
It’s not about race at all, I just care about how she looks. And it just doesn’t matchup with the version I watched when I was 6 years old.
Every live action remake Disney production generates has one thing in common with each other. The live action remakes do not do justice to the originals. The live action remakes provide employment for some actors and film people, Disney makes some quick money because people will go see it simply because it's a Disney production, no need for creativity / new music score / original screen play and give the appearance of some kind of social consciousness. It is insulting how Disney management arrogantly looks down on the viewing public, the fans, as gullible minions to be used for quick financial gains.
 

CaptainAmerica

Premium Member
Every live action remake Disney production generates has one thing in common with each other. The live action remakes do not do justice to the originals. The live action remakes provide employment for some actors and film people, Disney makes some quick money because people will go see it simply because it's a Disney production, no need for creativity / new music score / original screen play and give the appearance of some kind of social consciousness. It is insulting how Disney management arrogantly looks down on the viewing public, the fans, as gullible minions to be used for quick financial gains.
I thought Cinderella was quite good.
 

itsy bitsy spider

Well-Known Member
That's true, the Blue Fairy, The Coachman and Stromboli are awful in the new Pinocchio. They look nothing like the Disney animated versions.

The Diehard Disney apologists will not mention when people have a problem with certain other characters (Galadriel, Maleficent, Aladdin, Lumiere). It doesn't fit with their narrative they are going with to the grave.
 

Californian Elitist

Well-Known Member
That's exactly how my white daughters reacted to the trailer. Little girls love mermaids.

To reiterate, since I know not every person reads every post, I have no problem with this casting. But that doesn't mean it's "important." In fact, the argument up until this point has been the opposite, that it shouldn't matter what race or nationality she is, an argument that I agree with.

Position 1: "It's important that she's white." <--- Racist people say this.
Position 2: "It doesn't matter what race she is." <--- We were here. This is the consensus mainstream opinion.
Position 3: "It's important that she's Black." <--- But you moved the goalpasts to here. This is where you get backlash.
It’s not important for YOU. But it is important for other people.

Your white daughters don’t necessarily matter here. They’re not growing up black.
 

spacemt354

Chili's
610,000 👍
1.7 million 👎
You're just like the "anti-woke" mob, but you're on the other side. So you saying this stuff is like "The Pot calling the Kettle black."
That's true, the Blue Fairy, The Coachman and Stromboli are awful in the new Pinocchio. They look nothing like the Disney animated versions.
Sigh. We've had this issue before on the imagineer forum.

These accounts all seem to come from the same source.
 

CaptainAmerica

Premium Member
It’s not important for YOU. But it is important for other people.
So what's our goal here, societally? Do we want little black girls and little white girls to play with each other, love the same movies, sing the same songs, and not even notice that their skin is different from each other? Because that's what I thought our goal was, and that's what I teach my kids. It doesn't matter what you look like, or what your friends look like, or what your friends' parents look like, because God made all of us special and what matters is who we are as individuals, not what group we belong to. Don't we want our children to be thinking about what dress is the most sparkly, which songs they like to sing in the bathtub, and which animal sidekick is the cutest, rather than the race of the actress playing the fictional mermaid? It's such an awful burden to impose on kids to make them worry about the legacy of slavery or Jim Crow or colonialism, just let them be freaking kids.

You seem to be preaching this kind of neo-segregationism where black girls can only have black role models and black heroes, and it's such a poisonous mindset. "You white girls go over here, this isn't for you." "You black girls go over there, this isn't for you."

Your white daughters don’t necessarily matter here.
Read this back to yourself. You're proud of having written this sentence?
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom