Professortango1
Well-Known Member
I'm not disputing that, just saying that it could provide an avenue for Disney to go as frilly-girly-princessy as possible in the Snow White redo, if "they" felt they already had the spookhouse genre covered in some capacity.
Now, Snow White does just about everything more effectively than Pinocchio barring the ending, so it wouldn't be my choice for them to do that. But I could see some toady exec making that argument.
You aren't disputing they are different yet you're trying to directly compare them? Snow White has the more effective feeling of being chased and hounded...because Pinocchio doesn't have that as a goal. Pinocchio has the more effective overwhelming scope and allure of the dangerous world...because Snow White doesn't have that as a goal. Its like saying Alice in Wonderland does it more effectively than Peter Pan.