doctornick
Well-Known Member
This keeps being asserted but I think it is grossly oversimplified. When Disney made Snow White, there was no soundtrack, no existing aesthetic, no existing sets, etc.
When Disney released Episode VII, there was an established soundtrack (Yes, John Williams wrote new pieces, but he had already developed "the feel"), established costume themes, established ship and uniform styles, and even some of the actual cast from previous movies.
Without being too snarky, aside from Budget and the actual ownership rights, Disney's contribution to the Star Wars universe is creatively equivalent to fan fiction. Not that that is a bad thing. It just isn't the same as taking a purely written fairy tale and creating a visual and aural universe out of it.
That's a good argument.
I still think it undersells what Disney is doing by creating new content within established brands -- it's not as simple as just "buying" the IPs because you still have to make new content but I do agree that's easier to add to established brands than create something entirely brand new.
That said, I think you could make a good point that the likes of Zootopia or Inside Out are as original or creative as anything Disney has ever done.