Disney (and others) at the Box Office - Current State of Affairs

Disney Irish

Premium Member
Maybe similar, but inflation is much higher, and the reshoots were EXTENSIVE for this one. Let me stress, I'm not saying the numbers are wrong (or even insinuating it), I completely believe that's the numbers, it's just a lot less than I expected, which is a good thing for Marvel.
True inflation is higher but it’s still comparable, which is why I’m not surprised. Even if it was said it was $200M I wouldn’t be surprised as that is what we’ve come to expect from Disney.

But overall I am happy to see they are reducing budgets.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
View attachment 839280
This movie looked doomed after the first couple weeks, this seems to be a growing trend, movies that start bad but keep trudging along to eventually become profitable.
What it shows is don’t count the Mouse out until it’s cross the finish line. This is why all the commentary and calling movies failures before they even complete their theatrical run is silly and in many cases down right insulting.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
Btw, @BrianLo correct me if I’m wrong, but outside of their small budget Searchlight movies (which we don’t know the budgets on anyways) Disney had a 2024 with no movie loses. I don’t think any other studio can boast such a claim last year, or really any year in modern times.
 

Disstevefan1

Well-Known Member
View attachment 839280
This movie looked doomed after the first couple weeks, this seems to be a growing trend, movies that start bad but keep trudging along to eventually become profitable.
Goes to show you, if Disney can keep a movie in the Theater long enough it should break even or make money.
Disney is powerful and can make deals to keep movies in theaters as long as possible.

Lion King is a super popular IP. Its too bad there are so few attractions in the parks.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
Btw, @BrianLo correct me if I’m wrong, but outside of their small budget Searchlight movies (which we don’t know the budgets on anyways) Disney had a 2024 with no movie loses. I don’t think any other studio can boast such a claim last year, or really any year in modern times.

Correct! And really the only searchlight film that isn’t micro would be a complete unknown and that just picked up an s-tonne of Oscar buzz, so I expect that will keep legging along.

They might have lost money on the Pixar re-releases if we get into the weeds, depends on how much they spent on marketing. But that’s micro and I really don’t think in normal circumstances we talk about re-releases.

It was an unusually successful 2024 rebound. Mufasa, IO2, Apes all definitely exceeded my expectations from this point last year; and we didn’t even know about Moana 2 yet.
 

MagicMouseFan

Well-Known Member
Last edited:

Disney Irish

Premium Member
Correct! And really the only searchlight film that isn’t micro would be a complete unknown and that just picked up an s-tonne of Oscar buzz, so I expect that will keep legging along.

They might have lost money on the Pixar re-releases if we get into the weeds, depends on how much they spent on marketing. But that’s micro and I really don’t think in normal circumstances we talk about re-releases.

It was an unusually successful 2024 rebound. Mufasa, IO2, Apes all definitely exceeded my expectations from this point last year; and we didn’t even know about Moana 2 yet.
What a difference a year makes! Iger for all his flaws have turned around Disney and put Studios back on a path for success.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
This is not exhaustive, but a quick highlights tour of some of the biggest flops in what is considered a quite successful decade theatrically for Disney.

As @MisterPenguin has highlighted often in the past, there’s a relatively common denominator, I’m sure you can spot it.

2010-Prince of Persia/The Sorcerers Apprentice
2011-Mars Needs Moms
2012-John Carter
2013-The Lone Ranger
2014-Muppet Most Wanted/Million dollar arm (modest misses)
2015-Tomorrowland/Good Dinosaur
2016-Alice Through the Looking Glass/The BFG
2017-Cars 3 (very modest miss)
2018-A Wrinkle in Time / Solo
2019-Dark Phoenix - though otherwise sort of not their fault and an epic year
 
Last edited:

Vegas Disney Fan

Well-Known Member
What a difference a year makes! Iger for all his flaws have turned around Disney and put Studios back on a path for success.
I give him a ton of credit for slimming down the release schedule to relatively safe releases, Disneys reputation for quality storytelling was severely damaged at the end of 2023, I think it’s largely been restored now, he absolutely deserves praise for that because another 2023 may have taken a decade to recover from. It’ll be interesting to see if that reputation and success carries over to next year with a more varied and questionable release schedule.

I think this is true with D+ also, still stumbled with some of the shows but overall the quality over quantity approach worked pretty well.
 
Last edited:

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I give him a ton of credit for slimming down the release schedule to relatively safe releases, Disneys reputation for quality storytelling was severely damaged at the end of 2023, I think it’s largely been restored now, he absolutely deserves praise for that because another 2023 may have taken a decade to recover from. It’ll be interesting to see if that reputation and success carries over to next year with a more varied and questionable release schedule.
He would have been given the blame had Disney had another dismal year, so he deserves the credit when they have success too. And 2024 was highly successful. Also outside of Mufasa I believe most every other film was started or finished after his return. Moana 2 was most certainly his decision to turn it from a streaming show to a theatrical release.

Edit - I see you edited your post to remove your question on how much credit Iger deserves.
 

Vegas Disney Fan

Well-Known Member
He would have been given the blame had Disney had another dismal year, so he deserves the credit when they have success too. And 2024 was highly successful. Also outside of Mufasa I believe most every other film was started or finished after his return. Moana 2 was most certainly his decision to turn it from a streaming show to a theatrical release.

Edit - I see you edited your post to remove your question on how much credit Iger deserves.
I’m trying to cut down on my “feedback sandwich” posts which include negativity in an otherwise positive post. I’m so used to doing it I usually don’t realize I did it until I get called on it or reread my post though
 

DKampy

Well-Known Member
Maybe similar, but inflation is much higher, and the reshoots were EXTENSIVE for this one. Let me stress, I'm not saying the numbers are wrong (or even insinuating it), I completely believe that's the numbers, it's just a lot less than I expected, which is a good thing for Marvel.
As Disney Marvel went on the OG Avenger cast got more and more expensive…. Without any original cast members… I am sure they can save a bit of money there… one plus in going with a Mackey Captain America
 

brideck

Well-Known Member
Correct! And really the only searchlight film that isn’t micro would be a complete unknown and that just picked up an s-tonne of Oscar buzz, so I expect that will keep legging along.

I think The First Omen (20th Century) was probably a little in the negative, no? That was actually a surprising miss for me at the time.

But obviously, everything else was a win on the scorecard.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
I think The First Omen (20th Century) was probably a little in the negative, no? That was actually a surprising miss for me at the time.

But obviously, everything else was a win on the scorecard.

I was throwing that into the micro and very unknown break even category. If it lost money after streaming revenue, it’s almost a rounding error.

Certainly we can put a caveat that this year had no massive bombs, along with maybe 2017 if we’re being generous to the Cars franchise as a whole.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
I think The First Omen (20th Century) was probably a little in the negative, no? That was actually a surprising miss for me at the time.

But obviously, everything else was a win on the scorecard.
I'd technically put First Omen under Searchlight even though it was released under the 20th Century banner due to its very low budget. If it hadn't been part of the Omen franchise it would have been under the Searchlight banner.
 

Tony the Tigger

Well-Known Member
Let's be honest, hardly anyone, besides a small sub group of movie fans, knows about any controversy with Snow White. If it doesn't do well at the box office it's because people chose to spend their money elsewhere and not because of anything that Zegler said.
In this case, I don’t know. I’ve seen a remarkably concerted effort of little micro pages all over my social media feeds trashing her, with many comments then also trashing her. Someone is out to get her. Half the country seem to think she’s the devil. I feel bad for her. I find her fairly compelling in the previews, and will likely see this film.

Captain America with a reported $180 million budget. Anti-doomers, are we back?
Similarly, since a lot of people don’t know the comics, really myself included until I heard about it, a lot of people think this is some kind of woke move, and are against the film. When these kinds of things happen, it is at least some measure of an obstacle. A percentage of the potential audience is not just disinterested, but actively against certain things.

For me, the Captain America films are some of the most boring and hard to watch. They turned me off from the entire Marvel category after initially being turned on by Iron Man. It wasn’t until very recently. I went back and watched everything. I’ve never been particularly interested in the new guy, either. So this will be one of those times where it depends. If we happen to be going to the movies that week and it’s out, we might see it. We might wait for streaming. It’s not a must see at this point. That can change if I hear good things. The biggest draw for me would be Harrison Ford.
I think The First Omen (20th Century) was probably a little in the negative, no? That was actually a surprising miss for me at the time.

But obviously, everything else was a win on the scorecard.
You just reminded me, I can’t remember if I ever got around to seeing this. I remember being somewhat interested. I have no recollection. The only thing I can think of in my head is the Liev Schreiber version. 🤣
 

LSLS

Well-Known Member
As Disney Marvel went on the OG Avenger cast got more and more expensive…. Without any original cast members… I am sure they can save a bit of money there… one plus in going with a Mackey Captain America
Sure, but I can't imagine Harrisson Ford is costing less. And according to some of the people who were in the movie, they said they essentially shot the movie twice with the amount of reshoots. But whatever, I'm glad it's in that range (I was expecting $220 or more personally), gives it a good change to make a profit, which would be good for the future of the MCU and Falco in particular.
 

MagicMouseFan

Well-Known Member
Source?…. Because I will take a trade over some random blogger
I couldn’t find anything confirming that half the movie was reshot, but there were significant and costly reshoots.

From Vulture:

Early test screenings of Brave New World, which hits theaters February 14, were reportedly disastrous, prompting expensive reshoots with major sequences cut from the film. According to a technical crew member on the film with knowledge of both the screenings and the reshoot process (which also took place last year), the character portrayed by Harrison Ford — Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross, a demagogic military leader who morphs into an irrational, orange-hued superhuman — created unforeseen political resonances for the studio in an inaugural year.

“He’s this very powerful general who becomes kind of a fascist and turns into a raging Red Hulk. That was seen as an allusion to Trump,” this source explains. “Disney was realizing, Hey, we’ve been bleeding for a while. Let’s try not to off our core base anymore than we have been over the past couple of years.””

 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom