NearTheEars
Well-Known Member
I never said I'm not bias. And kitschy wasn't meant in a derogatory manner. The original tower was clearly trying to capture the feeling of the original TV show with direct projections of Rod Serling, the animated spiral, and the eye and window appearing throughout. The original creation didn't try and update or modernize these iconic things, instead they embraced the feel of the show. Fun, well written, and full of 1950's low budget charm and creativity. I believe this was a conscious choice Disney made and it is effective.
For the newer Towers the re-recorded narration is darker and more menacing as is the music. They've replaced the callbacks to the show with more fright-based imagery and selling the ghost story aspect more.
The original has an ethereal feel with scenes quietly fading away as we feel like we're drifting through another realm. The new towers are focused more on Haunted house imagery. We don't see a window float away, instead we see a ghostly elevator drop, dooming the souls within. Then we drop. We don't pass through a nebulous realm between worlds, we see our reflection disappear as we become trapped in this hotel of spirits.
I prefer the menacing version with more modern effects as the 5th Dimension Room doesn't work for me and the hallway ending feels unfinished, but that's me.
I think the original is ambitious with making a thrill ride based around ghosts less of a horror attraction and more of cooky experience tied to the source material.
I think you are pretty spot on in your descriptions, but we certainly land on different ends of the spectrum as far as which is better. (And that's OK)