News Cars-Themed Attractions at Magic Kingdom

[MagicHappens1971]

That's your opinion and its fine. But eventually even pirates and mansion are going to be replaced. I'll be sad when they do but it will eventually happen.

Pirates & Mansion are never going anywhere.

 

[Ghost93]

Truthfully, hasn't Tom Sawyer Island had several security issues in the last year? The guy with the machte and then the bear?! Clearly they can't secure it. That's enough of a reason to get rid of it.

There was also that guy that killed Dr. Robinson and disappeared into the caves somewhere. Very dangerous.

 

[Beacon Joe]

No it's not -- it's directly in front of all of Frontierland and Liberty Square.

If it had been where we thought it was going behind BTMR, then yeah, but it isn't.

I like that Liberty Square, which is fashioned after east coast colonial towns will seemingly (based on fuzzy blue sky concept art) look upon snowy, craggy peaks that refect western geomorphology rather than the Appalachians, Green, White, Presidential ranges, etc.

 

[Disney Glimpses]

Could you please calm down and catch your breath.

This decision is not the end of the world.

No but it is the end of Disney World as a differentiator against the likes of Universal.

 

[Disney Glimpses]

I think you meant to reply from your other account.

No, I was not OP.

 

[the_rich]

Pirates & Mansion are never going anywhere.

I'm not saying soon. But they'll be gone eventually.(Could be 30, 40, 50 years from now)

 

[SteamboatJoe]

One more thing I’ve noticed . I do think in addition to the streams and waterfalls at the front of Cars that some of ROA will still exist around BTMRR. Yellow is the entrance, blue outline is water as it currently meets BTMRR and the blue arrow are new water features. It appears you would need to walk around a water future if you used the HM path (walk through Cars and arrive at the front of BTMRR).

I am optimistic that BTMRR gets some love too especially if the concept art is showing updates or enhanced features not currently on or around the attraction.

View attachment 808742

I was starting to think about this too. The northern portion could still exist and function given this artwork unless Villains annihilates the rest. The northern end is the longer of the two segments anyway. Some the scenery from the southern end could probably be relocated or replicated rather easily.

 

[Dear Prudence]

So, I'll be honest, as a Native person, I have mixed feelings about TSI and Rivers of America, and while I do not even remotely claim to speak for anyone else, a lot of the ROA issues are honestly easily fixed with a little Native involvement.

I'm not, however, under any kind of delusion that any of this is for my benefit or in anyway benevolent lol. That's getting into paternalistic territory.

I think DL's solution to Tom Sawyer was perfect because they ran away to the island to be pirates. It was and is the perfect solution to the problem.

 

[el_super]

I agree…to an extent. But change for the sake of change isn’t good either. For example, if they decided tomorrow to rip up Pirates and replace with Moana…is that the right decision? Probably not…Pirates is still incredibly popular.

That's an important distinction: they don't change things that are popular, no matter what level of malice you assign to their decision making. They can't replace Pirates with Cars because it's still too popular. The other side of that argument is that they MUST replace things that are not popular anymore. They are not running a museum.

 

[basas]

That's your opinion and its fine. But eventually even pirates and mansion are going to be replaced. I'll be sad when they do but it will eventually

I'm not saying soon. But they'll be gone eventually.(Could be 30, 40, 50 years from now)

Maybe? Maybe not? No sense changing them while they still serve a purpose (which, I would argue, the RoA do).

 

[Charlie The Chatbox Ghost]

Why should Disney dedicate more space to areas the overwhelming majority of guests don’t want to frequent?

But by making the island accessible without the rafts, more people can go to it. More kids can run around the play areas, more people can get to the restaurant that would likely have more justification to be open all the time. We need quieter areas of the parks so they don't turn into super stressful, chaotic environments. The parks experience is already very overwhelming at times because of crowds and a lack of many places to go back and hide.

Last time I was at WDW, at one point my family and I found ourselves in the quiet back areas of the Morocco pavilion at Epcot. It was peaceful, quiet. A nice break from the insane crowds that were there that night. Same vibes on Tom Sawyer Island too. Parks need quieter, open spaces for people to explore and take in the atmosphere and escape from the insanity of the rest of the park.

 

[Charlie The Chatbox Ghost]

I'm not saying soon. But they'll be gone eventually.(Could be 30, 40, 50 years from now)

They both continue to have long lines and push tons of merchandise, which TSI does not. It's not an equal comparison.

 

[basas]

That's an important distinction: they don't change things that are popular, no matter what level of malice you assign to their decision making. They can't replace Pirates with Cars because it's still too popular. The other side of that argument is that they MUST replace things that are not popular anymore. They are not running a museum.

Well we know that isn’t true (see Splash Mountain), but I get your point.

However, there’s no evidence that RoA, the Liberty Belle etc are any more or less popular today than they were in 1971. They weren’t designed to be e-tickets…but they still serve a purpose.

 

[FiestaFunKid]

EVERY attraction should be replaced. The parks aren't museums. They have to continuously evolve.

This has become a go to cliche to justify any and all closures at anytime.

In reality, good stewardship of the parks requires much more nuance around what/when to remove and what to add. This is probably most impotant decision of park leadership and, in relation to their bloated compensation, the track record has not been great.

 

[Serpico Jones]

TSI and RoA needed to go. Disney made the right move replacing the dated TSI with a beloved IP.

The only thing surprising about TSI being removed is that it didn’t happen sooner.

 

[Chef idea Mickey`=]

What bothers me most about all the Disney Concepts is none of them come to fruition better or identical in grand and scale as exciting the concept art shows. Im afraid the next Cars one will be a let down from this one so far scaled back that you would only dream of something like this first concept map.

 

[Sectorkeeper71]

I’ve come to this conclusion. I’d be ok with:

Then covering over the rivers of America and putting in something more fitting for Frontierland (something like grizzly river run or western river expedition for example)

or

Putting a cars area on the opposite side of the river from thunder mountain that feels like it’s more distinct area.

Doing the two together just seems strange to me

 

[JMcMahonEsq]

MK's TSI is so much better than the DL equivalent. Just because a lot of people are foolish to not enjoy it doesn't mean it has no value.

No that’s 100% what it means. If people aren’t enjoying it in one location, but are enjoying it in another, it means objectively the DL version is satisfying its guest better than Orlando. Just because you like it, doesn’t mean that others are foolish not to like it.

 

[HuckleBerryFin]

No, but it is the end of Disney World. Like New Orleans, Pittsburgh, New York, and every other major riverfront city, the water is the heart of the city. Remove the Mississippi, the Allegheny/Monongahela/Ohio, and the Hudson from those cities and all that remains is cement. Water is necessary for life, and cutting off the supply will kill the Magic Kingdom.

it may be time to log off..

 

[Dan13]

I am so disappointed with this announcement although not surprised. The “new” Disney “leadership “ is determined to completely reimagine Magic Kingdom into something that has lost all of its’ magic and nostalgia. They have completely lost their way.