Patricia Melton
Well-Known Member
I'm sure his contract with Disney allows him some creative approval but I'm not sure how much. There is a reason J.K. Rowling said no to Disney and if she had gone with them, I certainly don't think we would have gotten the scale/rides/unique merchandise...everything really that we have today at Universal. Disney made it clear they wanted creative control and that they didn't want to spend the money (Big mistake on their part).
I'd be curious to know the terms of Cameron-Disney contract. I hope Cameron got more creative control than Rowling was offered with Potter. If the TDO is fully or even mostly in charge, I think Avatar is going to end up botched because they will want to cut the budget and by extension, the scale of the attraction. That has been their pattern so far. And Avatar is a project that needs to have scale/at least one big ride to stay relevant even after the film series has concluded because Avatar is definitely not Potter when it comes to thinking about staying power. .
Bubbles --
You really made me think with this.
You are 100% correct that Rowling rejected Disney for two reasons: (1) She would not have had sign-off powers on a Potterland and (2) Disney wanted to be cheap and small-scale and she did not want that.
The big question I have --- and I hope the insiders reading this forum will chime in -- is "Did Disney learn a lesson from its failure to partner with Rowling, and the subsequent loss it sustained from missing out on the Potter rights?".
Because if they DID learn a lesson, then a deal with Cameron might have been TDO's way of trying to make up for the loss of Rowling's world. Specifically, would Disney have agreed to giving Cameron final approval and a guaranteed high-budget land to get him to sign the dotted line...because otherwise they'd be afraid that Cameron would go to Universal like Rowling did?
I don't know enough about TDO's mindset to guess, but I can give you a personal example of this from my own life. Before my husband retired, he was a franchise owner of restaurants. I won't name names, but my husband lost out on what turned out to be a really great opportunity to get in on the ground floor of a chain that was new to our state because he just didn't think the concept would catch on and he also felt that he'd need to sink too much into the initial startup. Well, someone else of course bought into this in our area and we missed out on that boat. A few years later, another opportunity that was similar presented itself and my husband LEAPT at the chance to buy-in...even though this franchise was even MORE stringent than the one he passed up a few years before. Missing out on Opportunity Number One made my husband more amenable to certain things when Opportunity Number Two came our way.
Incidentally...Opportunity Number Two never set the world on fire. My husband was an idiot not to see the potential of Opportunity Number One when he had the chance. He still regrets his mistake 25 years later.
I see TDO in my husband's shoes in this: they missed out on partnering with JK Rowling because they were stupidly cheap. So Cameron came along and they leapt at the chance to work with him. I bet they agreed to whatever Cameron wanted because refusing Rowling's criteria cost them a gold mine. But Cameron's world will never be as successful for them as Rowling's Harry Potter world would have been.