I dunno, I sortof thought it was a rather interesting thread with discussion. Scrolling through, the only sarcastic comments I read were people saying that others "don't understand youtube" and the like, but even that went into a more nuanced discussion about Maker studios and other things. Nothing really "blew up" until towards the bottom of the last page...so, not really seeing where you are getting that from.
With one exception, my post on page 1 certainly was "sarcastic", but you can ignore that, cause I'm old and crotchety and I've been on the net since the early 90s (yes, the early 90s) and watched it evolve (including when Break and ebaums were the video kings, well before youtube was even a sparkle in someones eye).
That said, that's my opinion. I could see a Maker's Studio presence as a small shop or section of a larger media shop having some limited success, but not a complete overhaul of DisneyQuest as a viable option.
Unique idea though. But, just because people didn't take to it, doesn't mean that they are personally attacking you, nor does it mean that they didn't ponder it before deciding they didn't like it (even if their response was a thumbs down gif).
If you think the idea is solid, defend it. But, there's no reason to take it personally when no one criticized you until you decided to ad hom (and, also missed my sarcasm with my post on page one).