Your projects will be due on Friday, October 16 at 11:59:59 EST/8:59:59 PST
I think the original post might have not been changed to the noon due dateReminder: Power of Veto projects are due in like 10 minutes unless it changed without me knowing
It doesn't say AM or PMI think the original post might have not been changed to the noon due date
No problem!I'm really sorry for using your picture Outbound, I had no time to make my own and yours was the best-looking one. Old don't get mad, think of it as your piece being so good that it was the only one I thought would look best, so good job to you!
My thoughts on my submission: It doesn't look like much, but she's got it where it counts, kid.
Wait it’s noon.It doesn't say AM or PM
I’m working for the next hour or so, so it’s probably too late. I thought it was due midnight... oh well, I’ll still submit something later but I get it if it doesn’t countSo I'm the only judge that's on right now I think... if you want to still do it, I think having a couple extra hours is okay because we weren't clear on the prompt... although if Tiki or Mickeyfan disagree, I'm not a senior judge yet, so they overrule
Interesting, cause I thought it was going to be a world's fair style Tomorrowland.Project Veto Reviews (PerGron can be added later)
Outbound - What can I say, this was really strong - from the eloquent backstories to the path on the map throughout the park, mostly everything seemed to work for me. To stay consistent I do remember this being an option when brainstorming Harbortown and we dismissed it originally because like the Discovery River Boats in DAK, we thought it'd take too long to sail around the park.
Given that however, I think you made some strong adjustments to ensure that it works the best it can, and thematically this is one of if not the best option for in-park transportation in my view.
Creativity - 10/10
Realism - 9/10
Detail - 5/5
--------------------------
Total 24/25
Pi on my cake - I like horses as much as the next guy, and they might work for perhaps a future Frontierland or Harbortown aesthetics, but for a full park transportation it feels a bit over the top in terms of care for the horses themselves, maintenance, and facilitation of guests. A nice idea for in-land transportation in lieu of a trolley or motor car however. I also liked the makeshift map - while maybe not the best looking it does show the progression of the season up until this point and helped the detail score.
Creativity - 10/10
Realism - 6/10
Detail - 5/5
---------------------------
Total 21/25
D Hulk - Well, as a roller coaster enthusiast I approve. Other than that, umm, well, without getting the Hulk too mad, you'll have to take the stairs on this one.
Creativity - 10/10
Realism - 5/10
Detail - 4/5
--------------------------
Total 19/25
b-wolf - This was a very neat proposal! An underground train throughout the park would be interesting to see pulled off. I do like nuance to it as well I think in general it enables you to create something that doesn't have to fit with the theme of each land like an above-ground attraction might have to. Overall, very impressed by this. The only thing I'll add I think you have the potential to be really good in this game, I'd like to see you step out and try some concept art or a map as we continue on, it'll really help your presentations!
Creativity - 10/10
Realism - 9/10
Detail - 4/5
-------------------------------
Total 23/25
mickeynerd17 - Like the innovative approach with the Maglev, and I think in a group project it's okay to borrow with credit other people's illustrations so you did fine there. At the same time I think this approach without an established Tomorrowland yet puts folks in a bind to pick a futuristic style Tomorrowland rather than brainstorm other potential options. If Tomorrowlad was already established this would be higher on my list but otherwise it makes it tough to have this be the established transportation.
Creativity - 9/10
Realism - 8/10
Detail - 4/5
------------------------------
Total 21/25
So, I thought that having a futuristic transport would work since it would be a world's fair land anyway, but oh well.One of your stops must be in *insert World's Fair land name here*
That was me forgetting to edit the prompt lol... I think the prompt was made when you guys seemed like you were leaning towards the world's fair idea for the Small World land and then when I copied and pasted it from the judges PM, I forgot to edit it outInteresting, cause I thought it was going to be a world's fair style Tomorrowland.
Goofyyukyuk literally said it here:
So, I thought that having a futuristic transport would work since it would be a world's fair land anyway, but oh well.
DammitThat was me forgetting to edit the prompt lol... I think the prompt was made when you guys seemed like you were leaning towards the world's fair idea for the Small World land and then when I copied and pasted it from the judges PM, I forgot to edit it out
That was an early brainstorming concept, but ultimately the project veered away from the Tomorrowland influences and went in the crafts direction akin to more traditional it's a small world tropes.Interesting, cause I thought it was going to be a world's fair style Tomorrowland.
Goofyyukyuk literally said it here:
So, I thought that having a futuristic transport would work since it would be a world's fair land anyway, but oh well.
I guess it'll be up to the other judges... we're not doing the podcast until tonight, so in my opinion, it's okay, especially considering 3 judges still haven't put in their scores yet so it's not like you're holding anything upI’m working for the next hour or so, so it’s probably too late. I thought it was due midnight... oh well, I’ll still submit something later but I get it if it doesn’t count
I understand your reasoning. I just messed up.That was an early brainstorming concept, but ultimately the project veered away from the Tomorrowland influences and went in the crafts direction akin to more traditional it's a small world tropes.
You had mentioned the main station was in Tomorrowland my only concern with that is Tomorrowland proper isn't designed yet so it would be facilitating the direction of the land by need rather than organically. That's all!
I'm really sorry for using your picture Outbound, I had no time to make my own and yours was the best-looking one. Old don't get mad, think of it as your piece being so good that it was the only one I thought would look best, so good job to you!
My thoughts on my submission: It doesn't look like much, but she's got it where it counts, kid.
I'll admit, I was very close to asking to use that map too lol. But I thought the hodgepodge of what we have so far would be funny hahaNo problem!
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.