I disagree with much of your premise. I was there within the first 10 showings of ROE and it almost brought me to tears it was so good, I didn't even know the story ahead of time but I realized what it was as the images were being shown on the old globe and was perplexed at the torches being one short (until of course the reveal at the end). What is the story of this show? How badly can we butcher music from our films? WOC out at CA was a hit from the very first showing. Fantazmic at DL was a hit on day one and only got better with age. BravaSEAmo at TDS was a hit from day one. The difference is that each of those had a story line and flowed easily from scene to seen as opposed to this travesty which is downright jarring. Have of the musical adaptations of "Disney Classics" are done with an emphasis on being new and edgy to the point they are had to recognize, and of course they had to use a myriad of languages so that most people can't even understand them in the name of being multicultural. The technology in the show seems to be there mostly for the sake of the technology, what do those slow moving arms coming out from time to time add to the story, especially since they do the same 3-5 movements over and over. What does the center projection screen add other than highlighting the fact that someone didn't understand this show is viewable from 360 degrees - only about 15-20 degrees in from of USA Pavilion and bridge to future world can see it. The musical score, the obvious reason being to promote as many Disney DVDs and downloads as possible doesn't even segue from song to song, it just cuts. I've heard better mixing on a bar jukebox at 1:30 in the morning. On top of that, it completely demolishes the beauty and the calm of the lagoon during the day with at best so so fountains. Speaking of which, I guess since WOC was a success they had to try doing WOCish water tricks in the lagoon even though they have been saying for years they couldn't. Turns out they were right. I tried very hard to keep an open mind but now that I've seen a bunch of videos I can say, without reservation, yuck! Disney might replace it earlier than you think though because if you remember from long ago Epcot Forever threads there reason for that show (which was better than this train wreck) was to keep people around to buy the expensive meals at the restaurants and this mess won't keep anyone Disney did the projections on Fantasmic, live footage for Reflections of Earth, Happily Ever After. I like to use the beacon lighting on Spaceship Earth for example. That’s an old school way of entertainment there. Playing the music and what little they have to work with and make a show is incredible. Adding vocals and imagery has turned into an easy way out and there to reliant on that now. It’s hard to make a show without vocals and imagery and still get the story or at least the theme out there. That’s what made Disney so great. That’s why Reflections of Earth and Happily Ever After went over so well.