I appreciate the thematic issues at DHS but suspect 95% of patrons simply don’t notice. IMHO their attention is on “rides” and characters along with some interest in “shows”, not on whether the areas fit well together thematically. Furthermore, I suggest most have small children in tow. No matter what adults like to think, WDW continues to market towards the kiddie crowd.
Today, DHS has only 4 “rides” that draw people in: TOT, RnRC, ST, and TSM. If you’re a family with small children, TOT and RnRC are out, leaving you with just ST (assuming the children are over 40”) and TSM. TSM’s long lines are discouraging.
In terms of “shows”, Little Mermaid and Disney Junior are sure to please the young ones, maybe Beauty and the Beast as well. Mom and Dad might want to see Indiana Jones and will drag the youngsters along, even if the kids have never seen an Indy movie. Despite the recent movie and as evidenced by the theater always being 2/3 empty, I don’t think most kiddies even know who the Muppets are. Backlot Tour, American Idol, Disney Animation, and GMR are “grown up”, not much of an appeal to families with small children. Most simply don’t “get” One Man’s Dream. LMA suffers similarly; perhaps calling it the “Car Stunt Show” might have helped. When it comes to shows, DHS is top-heavy. Kids have a hard time sitting still. At best, you’re going to get them sitting for 4 shows and I suspect 3 is a more realistic limit.
Adding this together, I suggest that WDW’s “typical” family is going to do 2 rides and 3 shows at DHS before deciding they are done and want to head back to MK where all the kiddie rides are. Having toured DHS with small children several times, we were always done in half a day. As an adult , I had things I wanted to do but the rest of the family always wanted to head elsewhere.
Carsland at DHS should be a resounding success but there’s a decent chance adding it to DHS would mean the typical WDW patron is going to simply skip one of the shows they might have seen and still scurry back to MK after half-a-day at DHS. This will not help DHS.
DHS’s problem is not disjointed themes. It’s that it has too many attractions that don’t appeal to the kiddie patrol. Carsland would help but possibly at the price of attendance at DHS’s remaining shows. I suspect rather than significantly boosting park attendance, Carsland at DHS might cause DHS’s remaining shows to be emptier than they already are. IMHO, the shows at DHS need to be completely reevaluated.
I went to MK during Thanksgiving week. People were packed on the walkways with long lines on all the rides. Yet Country Bear Jamboree and Laugh Factory were half-full. Carrousel of Progress (one of my family’s favorites), Hall of the Presidents, and the Enchanted Tiki Room were ghost towns. Even at a park as popular as MK, its shows largely were ignored during a holiday week.
You might think I’m suggesting DHS needs to be “dummed down” the way Epcot was. Maybe. IMHO, MK is the most “dumbed down” park at WDW. It also happens to be the most popular.
My hope was that the now renamed “What’s Next” presentation was going to include Carsland, perhaps even a vision for DHS. Given yesterday’s events, I now wonder if that ever was the case.