No one is saying that Splash should close right now. Yes, it should do if the park has capacity to take up the slack. If things were run how they used to be. But it can't. Years of under investment is to blame, as is a savage cutting of maintainence staffing and budget. In a way, it is sadly too late now to save this situation. A situation that is just one example of the problem with the bigger picture. 20 years ago the attraction would never have gotten this bad in the first place. And any sudden park issues could be soaked up with other offerings.
And this is the company that used to actually have a third Omnimax projector on permenant hire, under covers and just sat on standby incase one of the other 2 projectors used in the same pavilion went faulty.
For example.
First off, I'm saying that if these much of the attraction is broken - the attraction should close. There needs to be higher standards for show then their currently are.
As for what us fans can do. We're all Disney fans - for me, this type of thing has caused me to split time between Disney World and Disneyland. I will be pushing my family to do their 2013 Family trip in Disneyland as well.
To those of you comparing the standards of Disney World to your local amusement park - it's not a realistic comparison. The biggest difference is that the price point is no where near the same. A Disney World Vacation requires (for most people) a flight, a hotel room, possibly a rental car, and park tickets. Comparatively, your local amusement park visitor is usually within 2 hours of the park, or in the area for another reason and has decided to hit up the park for a one day visit.
Someone else made the comparison of the MLB to NBA, but I actually think there are a lot of parallels between the two. Sure, they're offering completely different sports, but the price point is similar. However, to look at it another way - A few years ago, I had the opportunity to shadow the GM of the Rays AAA team, the Durham Bulls. We talked a lot of baseball, but we also talked about business. I asked if his competition in the area was College sports. He pointedly told me that no, his competition are any other form of entertainment in the price range. Most notably, movie theaters.
There aren't too many places that you can go where for $85 you can be entertained for a full day over a variety of different mediums. We simplify things as being theme park attractions but consider the offerings at a park like the Animal Kingdom. You can see two Broadway style shows, see a 3D special effects show, ride a 20 minute African Safari, and ride a thrilling highly themed roller coaster. That's a pretty diverse selection and it's being offered by what is widely regarded as the most incomplete of the Disney parks.