Half the population of the U.S. earns $30,000 or less a year. The poverty line for a family of 4 is $25,100. So, clearly when you say "we are not wealthy by any means" all that is saying is that you are not part of the elite 1%. However, knowing the cost of all those things you mentioned (DVC, V&A chef table, and spa services) on TOP of park tickets/passes, souvenirs, and dining (on nights you don't go to V&A), trust me. You have money. Way more than half the people in the U.S. Maybe more than 2/3rds....or even 3/4ths.
Growing up, my family was very strictly middle class, and we couldn't afford a Disney vacation. This was back in the early 70's when WDW first opened. People talking about how it used to be for everyone, are simply smoking nostalgia, and not reality. I started going in 1978 not because I could afford to go, but because I was living in Orlando. If I wasn't living there, I could never have afforded to go there at that time. I've been working for over 40 years, and make a better wage now, so can afford some of the finer things in life. Can I afford a house in Golden Oak - heavens no. We don't make anywhere near enough for something like that. We pay cash for every trip - never charge - but we have to save just like anyone else who wishes to go there.
As far as "not one single item is new" that is only technically true in that nothing previously unannounced was revealed on the Crown web page (yet). However, several of the offerings are new in that they just were opened/announced within the past few years such as Club 33 at multiple parks in Disney World, more Delicious Disney dining events starting in 2016 and ramping up further in 2017, as well as Disney's Riviera Resort (which Disney has decided to bar access for anyone who buys a resale DVC membership...you know...someone who is a Disney fan but really doesn't have a lot of money.) which won't open until fall.
Hmm, so something that was announced over 3 years ago is still "new"? Yes, Club 33 is new, and that will only appeal to a VERY limited clientele - just like Walt's Club 33 in Disneyland. Unless we win the lottery, it's not something we could ever afford. Umm, and you have been fed misinformation about Riviera. People you buy resale at Riviera will have the 11 month booking window as owners at that resort, just like someone who has bought direct from Disney at Riviera. I will be the FIRST to state that DVC is NOT for everyone. It is a luxury item, and no one should ever expect to get anything out of it except reduced costs on resort stays during the life of the contract. Nothing more, nothing less.
The point of what many are saying is not, "Hey, we don't want people with money to have special things to enjoy spending it on!" What we are saying is that Disney's constant focus of late is on promoting, enhancing and creating elite offerings at the expense of the formerly free or lower-cost extras, and it's quite distasteful.
Please tell us what
free or lower-cost extras are now considered "elite only" items?
1. If Disney decides they want to hold special parties in the evenings that patrons must pay for in addition to their park ticket, that is fine. But continue to offer EMH at the parks that are not having a party that night so that lower income "guests" have something fun to do. The fancy pants party can keep their $100 soft-serve ice cream and popcorn (the one I get refilled in my popcorn bucket for $2). But don't just eliminate the evening EMH.
I completely agree with you in that the current morning AND evening EMH should continue for all time. No argument there at all. We don't think the After Hours are worth the money either.
2. If people want to buy DVC from an owner, then let them have all the rights of a DVC owner who bought direct from Disney. If you think resale buyers aren't paying enough then exercise your right of first refusal. Otherwise, shut up and quit restricting their enjoyment of a service that puts them in your compound in which you are almost guaranteed they will spend hundreds more on food and fun. Besides, you already got your money from the original owner. Move on.
Well, DVD makes the rules, and they are very upfront about them. If you bought resale up until 2011, you had the same rights as the original owners. Since then, they have tried to make buying direct a bigger perk than the money, with a few extras that can ALL go away whenever they want. When you consider that you can save thousands by buying resale, and what you can mostly save money wise is on APs (only $100 each), it takes years and years to break even on that purchase.
What "restriction" do you think is causing them to enjoy the savings on their resort room any less than those of us who bought direct? Please remember - the ONLY thing guaranteed - even to us direct owners - is that we will save money on our resort costs. NOTHING else is guaranteed, and can go away in a heartbeat at their discretion. NEVER buy into DVC for ANY perks. That is not the reason to buy at all. It is NOT an investment. As I said, it is a luxury purchase.
3. If people want to pay hundreds of dollars so they can ride Avatar 6 times in a row, let them. But why does Disney have to charge me a parking fee on top of my room charge when I stay at the All-Star resort? I clearly am on a budget if I'm staying here. Get your money from the people who are begging you to take it. They aren't going to be staying at the All-star anyway. So, go find them at the Deluxe resorts and find new and interesting ways of swindling them out of their money, but let the rest of us enjoy Disney the way we have in the past.
Why in heavens name would you ever want to drive while at Disney? Don't you drive enough at home? You're on vacation. You get Magical Express from the airport - which we use EVERY trip - and then buses, boats, and monorails while on property. There certainly isn't ANY reason to have to pay for parking.