That's not the argument, and has never been the argument. The point is that people who are positing Splash's closure as uniquely painful and unprecedented and "oh no I'll never be able to experience my favorite attraction again" have an opportunity to go and still ride Splash Mountain somewhere on this earth if they so desire. It's a lot more than a die hard fan of The Great Movie Ride has at their disposal.
Oh wait, I forgot, it doesn't matter because apparently no other ride that has closed is as important or *sacred* or whatever word is being used this week as Splash, and is therefore instantly invalidated because Splash is uniquely precious
I actually would prefer 2015 Disneyland to what's there right now. There was an energy to the 60th, and it was the last year where it really felt like things were overall going in a positive direction. DCA had never been better. Disneyland was in stellar shape. If the park had rode off into the sunset as its 2015 incarnation, I would have been fine with it.
Subsequently? Prices have gone up. Entertainment has been cut back (several smaller acts that no longer exist in particular, but remember when DCA had a parade too?) FP and MaxPass were downgraded in the shift to Genie+. Pirates' auction scene has been butchered. They insist on running a 50 year old zombie of a parade instead of the brand new, state of the art one they had in 2015-and they refuse to fix whatever "issues" the new parade allegedly has. The number of drinks at Trader Sams that activate effects, which used to be about half of the menu, has now been limited to only two drinks. Steakhouse 55 removed its signature dessert and then later closed. Hyperspace Mountain shows up whenever it wants, and I now have to hope that it won't show up in the limited window of time I have to visit the resort. You can't just get a paper ticket anymore, you have to seek it out. Mobile Order was introduced and made a previously easy and intuitive aspect of the park-ordering food-into a chore, and because restaurant staffing has been cut, you basically have to use it. Appetizers or sides that used to be included in your meal (bread at table service restaurants, the salad and gumbo at Blue Bayou, etc) now cost extra. Food portions are smaller and more expensive than they used to be. They leveled part of DTD seemingly before they had any idea what they were going to do with it. Of the attractions put in since then or changes that have been made, I'd only call one-Rise of the Resistance-a complete home run (with the slight caveat that I haven't done MMRR yet). Several of the others have been either redundant (Smuggler's, Webslingers) or resulted from the downgrading of existing attractions (Soarin', Animation Building, everything in Pixar Pier). DCA's atmosphere in particular has really taken a hit as IP rushes into the park without any regard for whether or not it fits or is a genuine improvement. For me, Disneyland is more take it or leave it, but I loved 2015 DCA and merely tolerate 2023 DCA.
There's still good stuff there, and there are things that were added subsequently that I enjoyed, although some have also been removed or have yet to return (my beloved poutine flatbread from Red Rose Taverne, Frozen at Hyperion). But even with the good changes that have occured and lasted, the place is overall more *compromised* than it was in 2015. This applies to the resort in general, but
especially to DCA.
"Death by a thousand cuts" may be a bit extreme for my personal feelings, because I'm not yet at the point where I have no interest in returning, but I would absolutely understand if someone chose to stop visiting because of all the negative changes that have happened over time. There's been plenty of decline that I can note in just the ten years I've been semi-regularly visiting, and I'm not even a local. The DLR of 2023 still has many strengths and good points, but I certainly cannot consider it to be the best that it's ever been.