If you were to ask a regular to Disneyland what they rate the worst land at the resort is, the majority would say A Bugs Land. It gets plenty of hate out west.
DHS needs those quality family rides, attractions that have been lacking since the beginning. However if they go ahead with this, it is the cheap and easy way out. Much of the criticism of this rumor stems from that sentiment. TDO had a choice to give Frozen the attraction or land it deserves. Instead they went the easy way and are overlaying an existing attraction. Meanwhile it appears Tokyo is going to do it right, how Orlando should have done it. Perhaps this is one small piece to a larger puzzle, but Disney has lost the confidence of many when it comes to Orlando. So it is easy to hear something like TSPL and immediately jump to conclusions and think, here we go again.
Disney has a chance to completely re-invent a Theme Park. If this comes to fruition TSPL is another example of the easy way out instead taking the challenge and being more creative. There are so many creative things they could do with the great IP’s they have. This is the Golden Age of Mediocrity and Disney is leading the charge.