After watching Disenchanted (which just made me sad more than anything else, particularly for poor, ultra-underused James Marsden), I switched over to the Harmonius live performance on D+. This was my first exposure to Harmonius in any form, and my takeaway is that...choices were made. Because this isn't just a normal performance presented exactly as it would be in the park, it's difficult to know how much my impressions would change if I saw the show in Epcot itself, but here are my impressions based only on this special.
This isn't necessarily a bad show, at least as shown in this special, but the show as presented does nothing to quell the criticism that this show simply does not fit in Epcot. Hopefully this will be taken as a lesson for someone in WDI about the important of context, and how important context is to determine meaning and reception. Because honestly, if this show was moved as is to DCA and replaced World of Color instead of being plunked into Epcot as the big replacement for Illuminations, I don't feel like reactions to what is actually there would be nearly as negative.
I don't understand Disney spending million dollars on nighttime shows and filming a special to publicize it, only to focus most of the filming on the live musicians and not the actual show. Don't get me wrong, I appreciate the live musicians and all, but...if you're filming something to publicize a show, perhaps you should...focus on the show? For far too much of this special, we are ultra close up on the musicians and the actual show is playing in the distant background, making it difficult to feel like we're getting a full picture of what the show actually is. It just reeks of insecurity.
"Let's sing Disney songs, but around the world and in different languages" always seemed desperate to me, and none of my concerns were addressed. Singing "I Wanna Be Like You," but in Hindi, definitely is not the flex that Disney seems to think it is.
This show does not appear to have been a total loss. There were some cool songs and segments utilized. There IS promise in the show. But all of it was overshadowed by a glaringly inappropriate venue, and the show simply can't overcome that even at its best.