This would be more akin to Disney’s Beach Club selling day passes for Stormalong Bay.
This is my biggest complaint at Atlantis as well.
I’ve only had a table once, and I stood outside the waterpark for an hour before it opened to be able to get one. The lines for slides are already long enough.
Supposedly they’re only offering “limited passes”. I didn’t realize that any location did this. The weird thing is, the one by me is directly next to Kings Island.. we pass it when going to the park..soccer games..dinner..etc etc, quite often. The parking lot is always full, so I don’t think they’re having a problem getting resort bookings!