I visited Batuu tonight for my first time. I strongly believe it is the most impressive theme park land ever built. The scope of the place is incredible and it's absolutely beautiful, especially at night. Despite this, I have a few nitpicks:
1. The whole place feels strangely lifeless. Somehow Pandora, an alien forest with NO visible creatures, feels more alive. Several things could improve this.
- First, kinetic visual movement is sorely needed.
- Second, audio and background noise. Though there are lots of little sound effects from all over the land, they are too infrequent. Most of the time I only heard the whir from all the fans placed around more than anything else. The lack of a constant background noise is odd and jarring. Note that I absolutely do NOT want Star Wars music blasted everywhere - that is one thing I dislike about Potter - everywhere you go the same familiar tracks from the movies' scores are blasting, reminding you that you're in a recreation of something from a movie. There should, however, be more ambient noise than there is. Ships flying overhead, and other little touches like that. They are there... but they don't seem to be enough.
- Third, there's a handful of characters that roam around, but there needs to be more.
2. Although I have no issues whatsoever with choosing to go with a new planet, and I am someone that enjoys the Disney Star Wars films... there really could be a few more familiar things. It feels like there's hardly even anything from even the Disney films.
3. Tonally, Smuggler's Run feels a little bit off from Disney's Star Wars films and is overly lighthearted, like they're not taking the source material seriously. Those queue announcements, for example, are downright cringey. Avatar: Flight of Passage has a much more ridiculous and silly premise to sell the guest, but it never once feels hokey, yet Smuggler's Run does.
But yeah, the place is beautiful, even with these issues I think it takes my new top spot for theme park lands. I think it's current issues will improve over time, especially with RotR opening.