Nobody is saying that you can't judge for yourself if you like something or if it'd be worth your money.
I'm saying that if you haven't done it, your opinion is uninformed by the experience itself. It makes sense that the opinion of someone who's been in the Starcruiser is more valuable than that of some guy who's never done it but posts over and over how dumb it is. How is this controversial (or worthy of snark)?
CM discounts are likely to be motivated by a variety of objectives, don't you think? It doesn't seem like that offer is going to reliably fill rooms, so I don't think that was the only goal of the discount.
I think most of us figured from the beginning that the Starcruiser was expensive and expected that they'd lower the price eventually. I suppose that indicates to you that the whole thing was a "screw-up?"