My issues with BoG start with a bad server and, possibly, a bad policy and then go on to bland food. How do you get French Onion Soup wrong? You don't use a beef based broth, so you can call it veggie. Of course, that makes me want to head to Chefs de France or the Grand Floridian Cafe where they know how to compute stuff. And cupcakes??!? I have never seen one in France, but American rubes like them.
As to being an OCD planner, that wasn't me. That was my 'traveling companion' and she must be obeyed. I just went along with it ... Although I may have made two ressies of my own.
As to Walt's, you had to have had a bad experience because I have been many times and it has always been good to great.