In skimming the last few pages, I chuckled about the Be Our Guest feedback. I thought I was about the only one who wasn't wild about that place after reading so many glowing reviews. I actually touched on most of the complaints in my own review of it, including the poor forced perspective and mess hall feel. Biggest for me was that the food was bland, despite a menu that really deviates from the norm. (I also think the Imagineer-tribute babies on the ceiling are creepy, something I haven't seen mentioned here.)
In fairness, I do give the place kudos for trying a more inventive menu (especially given that it's in Fantasyland), and I do generally think the restaurant is ornate and nicely done. To me, besides a couple issues with the design, which I otherwise think is good, the big issue is the food. It just isn't good.
Now, I don't make ADRs far enough in advance to have dined there for dinner (I guess @
WDW1974 is a closet obsessive planner?!
), so those are my thoughts on lunch. Perhaps I'll share my thoughts on dinner in 2016 when its popularity starts to wane!
Then again, I also thought Walt's in Disneyland Paris served disgusting food, but at least the design there was amazing, top to bottom...