Still waiting for one reputable point that you can make but have yet to hear one. But alas, I'm loving the hilarity.
Here's a few reputable points, based on fact, and decidely are not opinions...
By closest estimates, a little over 16 million people visited Walt Disney World last year. You are 1.
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh consistently maintains an attraction queue of over 30 minutes, even during some of the slowest seasons.
Test Track is by far one of the most popular attractions at Epcot, consistently maintaining an attraction wait queue of over 60 minutes.
Mission: Space is proof that WDW is willing to put a lot of money into a project to try something new. True, it does not maintain a larger queue, but I am of the opinion that it is because of its higher capacity and undeserved bad press concerning two accidents.
I do not have to take a poll of the guests, though I did get varied responses whenever the topic was breached (back in the day). Disney takes its own polls... The survey/research teams sole job is to judge popular opinion, and that is the way WDW can tell if a decision was a bad one or not. Its a process overseen by many people, and is a whole lot more scientific than "oh, a bunch of people on a Disney board online said this."
Your biggest failure in starting the thread is by not defining what a BAD DECISION really is... What defines a bad decision? Just about everything you mentioned, since its removal, has been more popular than ever before. You need to clarify what a "bad decision" is in your eyes. As a stockholder, making Epcot a park with more varied attraction experiences, and keeping Magic Kingdom appealing for a new generation are good decisions to me. As a parent, making sure that when I take my daughter on the Living Seas, she engaged enough to learn about the seas around her is a good decision to me. If I were a DVC member, giving me more value for the investment by making a resort I can enjoy is a good decision to me.
Walt Disney World is appealing to the 16 million people who are visiting that don't want a museum. I don't speak for everyone on this forum.. To the contrary, I speak for everyone who IS NOT on this forum. For the families who bring their children to enjoy a quick vacation before school starts. For the groups who have never visited before who have heard about all the great things that Disney has to offer. For the new parents who are excited to bring their child for the first time, and are wondering what their little girl can see and do.
The very essence of nostalgia drives us in this forum.
Really? I would be more apt to agree with your first point... Its our love of Disney that drives this forum... Nostalgia is great and all, but in the long run, as Edna says, "I never look back, darling, it distracts from the now." Live in the past all you want to, I choose to live in my Walt Disney World, right now. And I choose to be excited for the future of my favorite vacation resort.