I finished The Reading List. I enjoyed it for the most part. The story is good and I liked the characters. (Fair warning, could be triggering for some readers with issues dealing with depression, mental health, suicide)
It's mostly about the two main characters, though there are a lot of side characters, too. People have happened upon this list of books when they were going through something rough, like the list was made for them, and it ends up in the hands of several people. But the two main characters are a 17 year old girl and an elderly man. The girl is working at the local library, something she doesn't really enjoy, having never been a reader herself. When an elderly man comes in looking for a recommendation, she's really rude. A regular at the library hands her a book and makes it clear that he'd recommend it, and maybe she could pass it on to the elderly man. Inside the book, she finds the list. As she starts to read, it helps her open up and get away from the problems in her own life, and when she recommends the book to the man, he experiences similar. Together, they form a beautiful friendship, reading and discussing the books, and then letting each other see more into their lives.
The idea is really sweet, and fun to follow along on their journey. I've read all but 2 of the books on the list, and I've also read one of the other books mentioned that's NOT on the list. But most of them I read a LONG time ago, and I really don't remember much about them, so I don't know if the portrayal of them is accurate. But the way Pride and Prejudice is discribed is not at ALL correct. Characters are completely different, one of the side characters calls it "nineteenth-century smut". I don't know what her definition of "smut" is, but considering there is no physical contact outside of dancing, there is no handholding or kissing or anything, I'd hardly call it smut. It's hard to believe the author of The Reading List has actually READ Pride and Prejudice.
I wouldn't go so far as to say you shouldn't read it, because overall it was a fun read, but just beware that if you have read any of the books on the list, they may or may not bear any resemblance to the actual books. I can't vouch for them, because I haven't read any of them recently enough (other than P&P, which is one of my all-time favorites) to know whether they are described well.
I decided to re-read To Kill a Mockingbird, since I haven't read it in over 30 years....I was in high school. That's the first book on The Reading List, and I wanted to see how closely it relates, and it's just a good book and a classic and it's one of those books that I feel like everyone should have read at some point. Since I can't remember much about it, I figure it's time to read it again and I had a copy here, so why not.