MarkTwain
Well-Known Member
I just wanted to take a step a back and comment on a few things.
First, the general response on WDWmagic seems to be completely unanimous: we pretty much all hate this idea. Most of the people here are either locals that occasionally enjoy a more spontaneous trip to the parks, or are people who visit often enough that we have a general idea on how to handle the parks on our own terms. So there's those two audiences that are against the idea.
That said, CaptainKidd makes a good point...
Just about anyone with kids is going to have trouble with this new system as well. Some days, kids are unexpectedly tired and need a nap back at the hotel in the mid-afternoon; sometimes kids are on their way to the Indy Speedway from Peter Pan, and see Winnie the Pooh on the way and have a sudden and intense desire to ride it; sometimes Buzz Lightyear is out in Tomorrowland, and little Johnny didn't know Buzz was going to be out and absolutely HAS to meet him, even though we have a Space Mountain reservation in four minutes. Despite the best efforts on behalf of the parents, kids are often unpredictable, and parents with kids are likely to have trouble with this degree of micro-planning.
So with locals, occasional regulars, and just about any family with kids going to be struggling with this new system, that leads me to wonder... who on earth, in terms of a broad demographic, was it designed for?? I don't even see the kind of first-time, only-time visitors enjoying the stress that this will cause them, between all of the researching attractions they've never heard of, attempting to schedule rides with little idea of what they're like or how far apart they actually are, and then the actual execution of attempting to act on the schedule. Does Disney actually think the vast majority of people are going to enjoy this idea? Are they prepared to suddenly repeal a $1 billion+ system when a huge sum of guest enjoyment polls come back negative? I mean, they can ignore the fanbois when they complain about the Adventurer's Club or the Lights of Winter, but this just seems like a move that's bad for everybody.
I really don't get it. :shrug:
First, the general response on WDWmagic seems to be completely unanimous: we pretty much all hate this idea. Most of the people here are either locals that occasionally enjoy a more spontaneous trip to the parks, or are people who visit often enough that we have a general idea on how to handle the parks on our own terms. So there's those two audiences that are against the idea.
That said, CaptainKidd makes a good point...
I agree with this. In fact, one major reason we're not going to WDW next summer is we were so exhausted this year from having to plan our trip like a CIA mission.
You change your mind. If you've got kids, plans change. They may want to go to the Magic Kingdom instead of Epcot one day. You may not be in the mood for Mexican food that you booked 6 months ago. Disney vacations, in order to do, see and eat what you want are becoming impossible without planning the majority of your trip in advance. And while planning is fun, it's becoming more of a pain, and less of a vacation.
Just about anyone with kids is going to have trouble with this new system as well. Some days, kids are unexpectedly tired and need a nap back at the hotel in the mid-afternoon; sometimes kids are on their way to the Indy Speedway from Peter Pan, and see Winnie the Pooh on the way and have a sudden and intense desire to ride it; sometimes Buzz Lightyear is out in Tomorrowland, and little Johnny didn't know Buzz was going to be out and absolutely HAS to meet him, even though we have a Space Mountain reservation in four minutes. Despite the best efforts on behalf of the parents, kids are often unpredictable, and parents with kids are likely to have trouble with this degree of micro-planning.
So with locals, occasional regulars, and just about any family with kids going to be struggling with this new system, that leads me to wonder... who on earth, in terms of a broad demographic, was it designed for?? I don't even see the kind of first-time, only-time visitors enjoying the stress that this will cause them, between all of the researching attractions they've never heard of, attempting to schedule rides with little idea of what they're like or how far apart they actually are, and then the actual execution of attempting to act on the schedule. Does Disney actually think the vast majority of people are going to enjoy this idea? Are they prepared to suddenly repeal a $1 billion+ system when a huge sum of guest enjoyment polls come back negative? I mean, they can ignore the fanbois when they complain about the Adventurer's Club or the Lights of Winter, but this just seems like a move that's bad for everybody.
I really don't get it. :shrug: