joking11 - good points!
There are many people that cannot stay onsite unless they stay at a Budget resort and I am glad WDW is building another one besides the All Star. I think they are well done and fun to look at. WDW is supposed to be bigger than life and magical, and those resorts really play on that!
Sure, they are heavily themed, even cheesy, but that is what some people like about them. I for one! Now, since we always stay onsite, I cannot stand hotels without theming. Recently I have gone to some nice hotels (Crowne Plaza, Ritz, etc) and have been unhappy. Sure, they are really nice and the staff is great, but I miss the themeing. That is just me.
Instead of going on and on about how much you hate PC and AS for that matter, why don't you just do us all a favor and NOT stay there. Personally I think you are insulting many families who can only afford those options.
I am a DVC member, so we usually stay at the deluxe locations, but I find the Budget and Moderates to be fun and great for families!
And on the topic of offsite or WDW Budget???!!! WDW Budget wins hands down. If you are going on a "WDW vacation" you really should stay on property. Being on property keeps the magic going all the time. I can stay at a Days Inn at home.
JMHO.
Kamy