I went to the party last week and thought it was an amazing value. You get extra fireworks, extra parade, tons of free stuff, the dance parties, there are (or were) zero lines (I mean seriously Space Mountain cast members were waiting for people to fill the trains!). I didn't see it as money-grabbing at all, if anything I saw it as a value. Getting to go into the Magic Kingdom from 4:30-12:30 for under 40 bucks is a value in itself yet alone all the other stuff that comes with it.
I'm excited to see it might happen in the fall, I'll have to check it out again.
I tend to agree with that sentiment, but in the interest of devil's advocate, can I ask : how large a group did you go with?
Obviously, the cost goes up exponentially for families versus groups of a couple of adults. I take about half my trips solo, a fourth with one or two other adults, and a forth with the whole family. When planning the non-solo trips (especially the whole family ones) I often have to remind myself that what may be financially no big deal when I'm on my own suddenly becomes a much bigger expense with more people.
This mainly applies to tickets and meals; when you are talking what amounts to almost fifty bucks a person (forty if you get a discount) for five hours in the MK (assuming you have daytime admission anyway; I agree it's a better value when you use the "after 4PM" admission on the party ticket), you really need to weigh the pros and cons. For a family of four that's an additional $200 - the cost of a plane ticket (for some of us), the price of two character meals (again for the family of 4), a weeks car rental if you get a super-good deal.
So while I wish there was a Pirates and Princess party when I go in early May, and I'd gladly pay the $ just for the fireworks and parade (I hate daytime parades, but adore nighttime ones), I totally can understand why it's a tough decision for some. It's also been said that the P&P parties were sparsely attended; it sounds like that added to their value in terms of ride time, something to keep in mind versus the other parties where that isn't always the case.
I used to be a champion of the parties, but the last year or so they really have, especially with the Xmas ones, gone a bit too far. Having them so close together really makes planning tough if you are avoiding them. Pitty the poor people (i.e. the average visitor) that doesn't understand them ahead of time. The price has also gone up markedly, again, especially for the Xmas parties. It's no mystery that Disney would love to have four parties a week year-round, but there has got to be a threshold, and from the sparse attendance of the P&P already held it seems as if Disney is just about there.
While NSSHP and VMCP gets people to buy tickets because of the holidays involved, P&P is more of a "luxury" than a "must-do" because you are there at the right time of year. It also erodes the value of admission tickets in some consumers eyes (those who are savvy enough to know about them before arrival).
I'm all for parties, but I think we've seen as far as Disney can really take it, unless these P&P parties in August really do gangbusters. For all we know, they are just being done to recoup the investment in the specialized entertainment and we'll never hear from them again. I'm sure it won't be that simple, but fifty bucks a head for just a few hours of park time is a hard sell to families with no real holiday involved is a tough sell unless you offer something really spectacular. When bringing my family down, I really have to question if $200 is worth it for fireworks and a parade when the rides are just as easy to see for us because we are always at the gates when they open the parks in the AM.
I'll be very interested to see how the August parties fare.
AEfx