_caleb
Well-Known Member
Sorry! I actually thought of your posts in the past when I wrote that about coasters. I didn't mean to offend you. I just prefer Disney's approach to other parks' approach.Why is it such a bad thing to have amazing coasters? IMO Disney is hurt by not having some world class coasters.
@UNCgolf did a terrific job at expressing my thoughts, and I've seen this "debate" pop up from time to time around here. But here's why I appreciate the non-coaster approach:
To me, the visible coaster track ruins the theming of a ride because it kind of breaks the illusion/story most of my favorite rides usually include. The Matterhorn, Space Mountain, Everest, RSR/TT, BTMRR, etc. are coasters, but because you don't see the tangle of tracks sitting there when you walk up to the ride or while you're waiting in the queue, your imagination can sort of take over. You're flying in space, you're on a runaway train, you're on a bobsled. It's a much more difficult and expensive approach, but the result is much more interesting to me.
I'm also not huge fan of the approaches to "theming" I see done of typical coasters. You can dress up the cars of a coaster train to look like motorcycles, a dragon, or cars, but it's obviously still a roller coaster because there's the track sitting there like a jungle gym.
It's also (apparently) really difficult to build a coaster for a broad range of preferences. The really intense giga-coasters and multiple-inversion things are not necessarily something the entire family is going to want to do. "Less intense," on a coaster, seems often to be considered "less fun." Disney's classic approach fills in the gap with imaginative theming.
All of this is why I'm not pleased with Slinky Dog Dash (maybe Andy was playing with a miniature roller coaster set in his back yard?), Goofy's Barnstormer or Flying School (cheap), R'n'RC (a plastic car on a coaster track, "driving" through Hollywood?), the Incredicoaster (layer a very meta "amusement park" theme with a bunch of plastic figures and a weak story) or the new TRON (the outdoor section seems to be more advertising than themed experience). I'm still not sure about GoTG.
Don't get me wrong, these are fun! But to me, roller coasters are fun because they move you around in ways you don't otherwise get to (safely) experience. Disney's better-themed rides try to "hide the tracks" both figuratively and literally.