Last i understood before i got too busy to personally run these contests was that the whole idea in participating was to have fun. Right from the get go, me, MSU, and MKT wanted to do photoshop contests but were very much aware that not everybody has an art degree, but we wanted them to participate none the less. More often than not have I seen people win THOSE contests who's best talent is originality (rather than artistic ability), and that was just fine. Its all fun. Even when we started offering "Prizes" to the winners, it was all still just for the sake of a good time.
Now...ok..I see the point of the argument, and both sides have their strong opinions on the matter. The best defence I can give and I guess the only thing i can point out is...no where in the contest rules does it state the seriousness of the contest. Meaning..theres no "No Joke Entries", or "Only serious considerations"...but then again...the seriousness of the entry is really based on the eye of the beholder.
As for "pre-judging" before the contest is over.....thats always happened since day 1. For whatever reason the person feels...but remember this..its just a comment..and who knows..they are not garunteed to be voting for the one they say they are (in fact, youd be suprised at how some people here vote).
So in conclusion...I must remind everybody that this is in fact a DISNEY FUN forum...theres no cash rewards involved, nor is everybody here a pro. Just relax and have fun..thats the purpose of all of these.
If there are any more questions regarding this matter, just PM me and I'll be glad to discuss it with any of you.
Thanks!