Let me put it this way:
If I'm in something like the Spiderman ride but it's Mario with a huge screen, sure, I'm shifting around a bit and have a parabolic screen in front of me but it's largely the same POV at playing Mario Kart and will be a disappointment.
Yes, it's slightly better with shifting the car around and the parabolic screen but it'll be a disappointment for video game based rides.
I don't even have a problem with it being used for Spiderman, Transformers, or Harry Potter. I sometimes think that they tend to rely on it a bit too much but, yeah, it works really well. The transitions in HP:FJ are pretty fantastic.
Copying the Spiderman ride as Mario Kart? That seems like a Disney move. It'll be a disappointment.