Those darn trees continue to inspire a visceral reaction from so many ...
Why?
Well because friends it's about more than "trees and plants."
More complex than "I like trees" or "I don't like the big trees blocking the castle."
It is about the fundamental design & development of the Magic Kingdom. Period.
I couldn't resist weighing in, because the hub is the most important design feature of the park, full stop. Prior to Disneyland, no one had designed a theme park to radiate out from the centre in such a complex yet simplistic way. In several design books they analyze the hub as a piece of design genius, a central anchor to which the rest of the entire park flows and operates from. It just works. And has been copied in parks the world over ever since.
The new hub so far is looking good. But prior to this we had better than "good." We had outstanding.
I genuinely believe TDO's current effort to deal with capacity in MK led them to evaluate a half hearted attempt for what the hub was intended to be. Current management are making a concerted effort to restore some landscaping to what was once a spectacular central plaza in the world's most visited theme park. Yet for so many - we still need it. The feeling of what once was - and never needed to be destroyed. Seriously, you shouldn't see Tomorrowland from Liberty Square. And we won't even bring up the tree massacre in Town Square. The current Town Square twigs look bare, sad and out of place. The trees they are installing in the new hub will indeed be a big change from the last decade of destruction.
The original hub trees prior to being removed in the early 2000's had 30 beautiful years of growth. They were grand, majestic and fitting for a plaza in front of "an old castle."
I am sentimental enough to want the old hub look and feel back, but pragmatic enough to know that will not happen. The problem with the Disney of today is it has gone from building things visitors never dreamed of or had seen before, to starting to fall short on the basics. Disney Parks needs more visionaries.
But hey - they have record revenue, a sky high stock price and incredible growth quarter after quarter. For me I believe you can be both a visionary and please Wall St. at the same time. The current folk don't feel the same. The current trajectory is hard to defend and hardly worth defending. Shanghai will have the greatest theme park the world has ever seen. And we're here debating trees. Welcome to Disney 2015.
The purists know what the hub means, what it looked like and what it should be.
To have the new trees achieve the same beauty, size and grandeur of what once was - we have to wait another 30 years of growth until the year 2045. But we already TDO will never let them get that far anyway ...